Evaluating a New Knee-Ankle-Foot Brace to Improve Gait in Children With Movement Disorders

Objective

The purpose of this protocol is to evaluate several configurations of a prototype Extension Assist Knee-Ankle-Foot Orthosis (EA-KAFO) in patients with cerebral palsy (CP), muscular dystrophy (MD), spina bifida (SB), or incomplete spinal cord injury (iSCI) who have knee extension deficiency. Three forms of assistance will be provided at the knee joint including a passive-damper component, functional electrical stimulation (FES) to the quadriceps, and a motorized assist. One form will provide controllable resistance at the knee to strengthen muscles and promote knee extension after the resistance is removed. These will be compared to traditional bracing which typically improves crouch by blocking some or all motion at one or both joints. We hypothesize that all assistive configurations will improve gait alignment and performance compared to the non-assisted conditions. We further hypothesize that a best solution for each participant will exist, but may vary across subjects due to the heterogeneity of these movement disorders. Preliminary data on brain activation using EEG will be collected during all walking conditions.

Study population

Thirty (30) subjects, age 5 and above, diagnosed with crouch gait from diplegic CP, (30) subjects, age 5 and above, with knee extension deficiency from MD, SB, or iSCI (15 from each group) and 10 age-matched healthy volunteers will be recruited.

Design

This protocol will evaluate an EA-KAFO prototype consisting of a custom fabricated brace combined with a modular knee joint with three modes of operation: hinge (no assist), a passive spring-damper, and an active motorized assist. Since crouch can also be precipitated at the ankle, the orthotic ankle joint has an adjustable dynamic resistance (ADR) mechanism that can be locked (passive assist) to simulate a standard brace, free, or provide variable resistance to assist knee extension. Additionally, we will combine quadriceps FES with the hinge and the passive damper to create two hybrid configurations. The hinge and the passive damper (Ultraflex ) knee modules, and ADR ankle brace are FDA-approved (Class I), commercially available devices. This protocol for evaluation of the active motorized joint module, the two hybrid configurations, and the controllable resistance device (PowerWalk by Agilik Technologies) has been reviewed by the FDA as a medical device study and was determined by the FDA to be non-significant risk. Healthy controls will come for one visit, and participants with movement disorders will complete 6-10 visits: 1) initial assessment and casting for custom leg brace; 2) EA-KAFO configuration; 3) initial data collection and practice; 4-5) accommodation to brace configurations; 6) final data collection. Additional accommodation visits may be added if necessary, up to the maximum of 10 total visits. Participants with movement disorders will be permitted to re-enroll in the protocol is a minimum of 1 year has passed from their prior final visit. Motion capture, force plates, and electromyography (EMG) will be used for gait analysis while electroencephalography (EEG) will measure brain activity during walking.

Outcome measures

The primary outcome is the amount of knee flexion during gait. The optimal solution for each individual will be that which provides the greatest reduction in peak knee angle. Secondary outcomes will include gait speed, knee extensor moment, and EEG activation profiles.

• INCLUSION CRITERIA:
• Age 5 years and above
• Either a healthy volunteer, have crouch gait with a diagnosis of spastic diplegic cerebral palsy, or have lower extremity weakness resulting in gait pathology from a diagnosis of muscular dystrophy, spina bifida, or incomplete spinal cord injury.
• Able to understand and follow simple directions based on parent report and physician observation during history and physical examination.
• Able to provide verbal/written assent.
• Less than 5 degrees of knee flexion contracture with hip extended in supine position. Hamstring contracture as assessed by straight leg raising test does not limit ability to participate in the study.
• Less than 10 degrees of plantar flexion contracture in neutral foot alignment.
• A measured foot-thigh angle of -10 to 25 degrees in prone position.
• Diagnosed with knee extension deficiency as indicated by a crouched posture during gait lacking at least 20 degrees of knee extension at mid stance during walking as assessed visually, knee extensor muscle weakness which prevents full extension of the limb, or reliance upon braces or other aids which lock the knee during walking. (The exact level of knee extension deficiency, or crouch, will be quantified after inclusion using gait analysis.)
• Able to walk at least 10 feet without stopping with or without a walking aid
• Agreement to not drink caffeine for 24 hours before each EEG assessment (CP only) visit because it can modify brain activity

Exclusion criteria

• Any neurological, musculoskeletal or cardiorespiratory injury, health condition, or diagnosis other than cerebral palsy, muscular dystrophy, spina bifida, or incomplete spinal cord injury that would affect the ability to walk as directed for short periods of time.
• Participation in this protocol within the previous 1 year.

ADDITIONAL EXCLUSION CRITERIA FOR INDIVIDUALS WITH CEREBRAL PALSY:

• A history of a seizure in the past year.
• Pregnancy