The KIT trial is a pragmatic, assessor-blinded, parallel 2-group, superiority randomized trial comparing the addition of EMDR to treatment as usual (TAU) versus waiting list (WL) and TAU for EMDR on symptoms of trauma in patients with SSDs. Participants will be randomized (1:1, block randomization by center and gender) to one of the two groups.
Aims, hypotheses, objectives:
- The primary aim is to investigate the effectiveness of EMDR as an add-on treatment for SSDs in standard clinical practice to target trauma symptoms.
- The secondary aim is to improve personalized therapy through the exploration of clinical stratification variables that may influence the effectiveness of EMDR.
- The long-term aim is to guide clinical practice and, if shown to be effective, to implement EMDR for patients with SSDs.
- The primary objective: EMDR and treatment as usual (TAU) compared to waiting list (WL) and TAU will reduce symptoms of trauma as measured by the ITQ (the International Trauma Questionnaire) in SSDs.
- The secondary objective: Stratification variables (trauma profile e.g. type, severity, timing; gender; biomarkers of stress and immune system reactivity; digital biomarkers of autonomous stress reactivity) influence the effectiveness of EMDR.
Expected results during the project period:
- The EMDR group will show less trauma symptoms compared to the WL control group by the end of treatment and possibly better functioning.
- No differences for costs nor serious adverse events will emerge between the groups at the end of treatment.
- Better outcomes are expected for trauma characterized by mild to moderate severity and later onset (e.g. related to experience of psychosis) as compared to CT (e.g. abuse and neglect).
- Although exploratory, patients with high levels of inflammation markers and/or hyperarousal and autonomous reactivity to trauma benefit most from EMDR.
EMDR for psychosis therapists: Eighteen trial therapists are currently fully trained in EMDR for psychosis in collaboration with Dr. Varese and colleagues at Manchester University, and receive monthly supervision. At least 24 more will be trained by early 2025. Assuming some therapist drop-out, 40 trial therapists will be recruiting SSD patients from their patient lists.
Assessments: Assessments will be performed for both groups by blinded research personnel at baseline, mid-treatment (12 weeks), end of treatment (6 months), 6- and 12-months post randomisation after end of treatment, in addition to digital patient feedback every 2 weeks from baseline to end of treatment at 6 months. The follow-up period after end of treatment is to examine long-term effects.
Eligible participants will be given initial information (verbal, web page, pamphlets) by the trial therapists, and then verbal and written information by research staff and asked for informed consent to partake in the trial. Primary outcome will be measured by the ITQ, a validated measure assessing reliable and clinically significant treatment-related change in trauma symptoms, including symptoms of PTSD and complex PTSD, used in outpatient clinics in Norway. Demographic and clinical information will be supplemented by clinical records and national health registers (e.g. Legemiddel-registeret, Kontroll og utbetaling av helserefusjoner, Kommunalt pasient og bruker-register, Norsk pasientregister, Nasjonalt kvalitetsregister for behandling i psykisk for voksne). Healthcare costs (e.g. use of all health care, health related financial support, transportation) will be captured by the study nurses at each assessment point and through health registers.
Patients' experience of trauma symptoms, working alliance and recovery will be assessed through Norse Feedback digital self-report. The digital assessment of the main outcome trauma symptoms (ITQ) will be captured every 2 weeks to closely monitor symptom fluctuations, while recovery and therapist alliance follow the time points of the study nurse assessments. This decentralised assessment is deemed particularly suitable in mental health. Assessment of somatic status (heartrate, weight, blood pressure) will be supplemented by blood samples of inflammation markers (CRP, IL6 and S-cortisol) and blood samples to the Bergen Psychosis Biobank for later analysis (e.g. IL18). The digital biomarkers heart rate variability, respiration rate (electro- cardiography/photoplethysmography), activation/ movement (actigraphy) and skin conductance (electrodermal activity) will be measured in-session by BioPoint wristworn biosensor. Trial therapists will rate fidelity, patient safety related adverse events (AE) and symptom exacerbation after each session, and variables facilitating implementation before/after trial participation. For symptom-specific items on suicidality, psychosis, substance abuse and hospitalisations. A sub-group of 30 patients will be asked about their experience of the therapy with a qualitative interview after treatment.
Work packages: Quality of assessments and analysis will be ensured by organising themes in work packages (WP) headed by national experts; WP0 Study management, WP1 Clinical outcome, WP2 Somatic status and biomarkers, WP3 Trauma characteristics, WP4 Treatment alliance and user experience, WP5 Study imple-mentation, WP6 Health economic evaluation.
Protocol adherence: Hospital Clinical Monitor will ensure protocol implementation and site responsibility. The protocol will be adhered to by all trial personnel, including trial therapists and local PIs to ensure patient safety and trial quality. There will be frequent meetings across sites and written agreements on site responsibility. All sites will use electronic report files (CRF) via Viedoc for patient case report forms.
Organization: The KIT trial is organized in Bergen Psychosis Research Group (BPRG) at Haukeland University Hospital. BPRG has extensive experience from clinical trials on SSDs (ClinicalTrials.gov IDs NCT00932529, NCT01446328, NCT03340909, NCT02597439, NCT02146547).
