Pilot Study of Melatonin and Epilepsy

Hypothesis 1: Melatonin treatment improves the quality of sleep in patients with epilepsy.

Various studies evaluating sleep problems in patients with epilepsy using questionnaires have shown that 34-45% patients have sleep related problems [1-3]. Cortesi et al reported that children with seizures had higher sleep difficulties than their siblings and controls[4]. Bedtime difficulties, sleep fragmentation, daytime sleepiness, snoring and parasomnia were reported as sleep problems in this population [2, 4]. Patients with refractory seizures and using multiple antiepileptic drugs(AED) showed worse problems[5]. On polysomnography (PSG) these patients show increased arousal index, increased sleep onset latency, fragmented or reduced REM sleep, increased stage shifts and increased Stage 1 sleep and decreased stage 2 and slow wave sleep. [6-9] Melatonin has been shown to decrease sleep onset latency and increase total sleep time and subjectively improve sleep in healthy individuals.[10-15]. Various studies using fast release and sustained release formulations have suggested improvement in sleep efficiency and decreased arousals as well.[16-18] In a randomized placebo controlled study by Gupta et al[19], Melatonin was shown to subjectively improve sleep in patients with epilepsy. Studies in children with neurodevelopmental delay and autism along with epilepsy have also reported similar findings.[17, 20-23] Rationale: There are significant sleep disturbances in children with epilepsy. Melatonin has been shown to improve sleep in this group of patients. However, all these studies report improvement based on parent report and only one study is placebo-controlled. Our study will assess this in randomized placebo controlled fashion and will provide both subjective and objective improvement in sleep with the primary outcome being improved sleep efficiency on PSG.

Hypothesis 2: Melatonin improves daytime functioning in terms of cognition, behavior and quality of life in the patients with epilepsy.

Poor sleep and epilepsy both have detrimental effect on cognition.[24-27] Melatonin by improving sleep may improve cognitive functioning in these patients.

Some patients with epilepsy have poor behavior and psychiatric function.[28-30] Severity of these problems are related to the worsening of the sleep problems.[2, 4] Melatonin by improving sleep may improve the behavior in these patients.

Epilepsy has negative effect on various aspects of the patients' life including social, behavioral, and academic [31, 32]. Questionnaires have been developed to assess the impact on overall quality of life of the patients [33, 34]. These tools are helpful to quickly and subjectively assess quality of life. Based on these studies, it has been shown that patients with refractory seizures have poor quality of life [33-37] and an improvement is seen if the seizure frequency is decreased.[38-41] There has been only one study reporting quality of life (QOL) after use of melatonin in patients with epilepsy. In this randomized placebo controlled study, significant improvement was seen in the cognitive, anxiety and behavior subscales of the QOLCE after use of melatonin.[42] To date, there are no studies reporting on the effect of melatonin on cognition or behavior in epilepsy patients.

Rationale: Poor behavior, cognition and quality of life have been reported in children with epilepsy and sleep disturbances. By improving the quality of sleep, melatonin will improve all these domains. QOLCE has been validated and used in epilepsy patients and will assess the QOL in these patients. Vigilance is the component of cognition that is most consistently and drastically affected by sleep deprivation. PVT measures "vigilant attention" and has been used widely in adult patients to assess the effect of sleep deprivation on cognition. It has been described as a very sensitive measure to see both acute and chronic effects of sleep deprivation. BASC-PRS has been used to assess behavior in children and is found equally useful in epilepsy patients as child behavior check list (CBCL). It is a sensitive tool to compare changes over shorter time span.

Hypothesis 3: Melatonin treatment decreases epileptic potential. Sleep deprivation has been known to induce seizures and epileptic discharges on EEG[43]. Seizures are also known to occur with change in the depth or rhythmicity of sleep.[43] Patients with epilepsy report sleep deprivation as a significant seizure precipitating factor [44, 45]. In a recent study, Haut et al reported that one hour of additional sleep on the preceding night decreased relative odds of a seizure on the subsequent day to 0.91[46]. In a study Oliveira reported that treatment of obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) decreased interictal epileptiform discharges.[47] The belief that fewer epileptiform discharges represent better seizure control is controversial. But a study suggested that decreasing epileptiform discharges on EEG improves behavior.[48] Studies investigating obstructive sleep apnea in patients with epilepsy have reported improvement in seizure control with treatment of OSA [49-54]. These suggest that stabilizing sleep has a beneficial effect on seizure control.

Many studies that evaluated melatonin in epilepsy patients report overall improvement in seizure control[17, 21], while others report no worsening of seizure control after the use of melatonin[20, 22, 23]. Coppola et al reported inconclusive results with regards to seizure control after melatonin use[55]. However, these studies are not powered to account for variability in seizure occurrence reported with epilepsy patients.

Rationale: There are no randomized controlled studies available to evaluate the effect of melatonin on seizure control in the children with epilepsy. This study will identify the effect of short term use of melatonin compared with placebo and will provide pilot data to evaluate this effect in a larger trial in future.

Inclusion criteria

• Age 6-11 years (prepubertal based on tanner staging)
• Patients with epilepsy (diagnosis based on ILAE).
• Normal intelligence based on school placement (defined as age appropriate; an IEP due to epilepsy related causes is acceptable as is placement in a higher grade) or IQ>70 (testing done with in 12 months of enrollment)
• No history of significant snoring- loud snoring every night outside of a room with closed door
• Combined score of 30 or more on sleep fragmentation, parasomnia and daytime drowsiness subscales on SBQ.

Exclusion criteria

• History of significant snoring- loud snoring every night heard outside of a room with closed door
• Diagnosis of obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) or periodic limb movement disorder on PSG
• Vagus nerve stimulator implanted
• History of a major psychiatric disease (e.g. psychosis, major depression)
• History of autism or pervasive development disorder
• Severe neuro-developmental disabilities, as determined by PI
• Clinically significant systemic organic disease, as determined by PI
• Current use of melatonin or sustained release melatonin
• Prior use of sustained release melatonin
• Current use of any hypnotic medications except for medications used as a rescue treatment for seizures
• Use of psychoactive or stimulant medication for attention deficit disorders
• Subjects with immune disorders, lympho-proliferative disorders, and those taking oral corticosteroids or other immuno-suppressants
• Subject or parent/legal guardian might not be reasonably expected to be compliant with or to complete the study.