Skip to main content
OpenTrials
Completed

NCT Number: NCT02032433

Extended-Release Naltrexone vs. Buprenorphine for Opioid Treatment

CTN-0051 assesses the comparative effectiveness of extended release injectable naltrexone (XR-NTX, Vivitrol®), an opioid antagonist recently approved and indicated for the prevention of relapse to opioid dependence, versus buprenorphine-naloxone (BUP-NX, Suboxone®), a high affinity partial agonist indicated for maintenance treatment of opioid dependence, as pharmacotherapeutic aids to recovery.

The study is conducted in 8 NIDA Clinical Trials Network affiliated community based treatment programs. Up to 600 eligible participants will be randomized to treatment with XR-NTX or BUP-NX for 24 weeks (sufficient to include 350 participants who are randomized more than 72 hours after their last opioid).

The primary goal of the study is to estimate the difference, if one exists, between XR-NTX and BUP-NX in the distribution of the time to relapse (i.e.., loss of persistent abstinence) during the 6-month trial. Secondary objectives are to: (1) compare outcome on XR-NTX versus BUP-NX across a range of clinical safety and secondary efficacy domains, and (2) explore demographic and, clinical, and genetic predictors of successful treatment and moderators of differential effectiveness (i.e., what variables may help clinicians choose which of these treatments is best for a given patient).), and (3) collect a limited dataset to permit analyses of economic costs and benefits of the two treatments.

Completed

Looking for future studies?

Notify Me

Key information

Conditions

Opioid Use Disorder Chemically-Induced Disorders Mental Disorders Narcotic-Related Disorders Opioid-Related Disorders Substance-Related Disorders

Age range

18 year and older

Sex eligibility

All sexes

Study type

Interventional

Phase

Phase 4

Primary location

Tarzana Treatment Centers, Tarzana, California, United States

Loading trial locations.

About this study

For opioid-dependent patients in the U.S. and most of the rest of the world, detoxification or detoxification followed by short term residential treatment, with the goal of achieving long-term abstinence from opioid misuse is a mainstay of treatment. Nonetheless, the majority of patients treated in this way will relapse to opioid misuse, leading to a costly and ineffectual cycle of readmission for repeated detoxifications.

The overarching goal of CTN-0051 is to foster adoption of new relapse-prevention pharmacotherapies in community-based treatment programs (CTPs) where these could have a substantial public health impact. To this end CTN-0051 assesses the comparative effectiveness of extended release injectable naltrexone (XR-NTX, Vivitrol®), an opioid antagonist recently approved and indicated for the prevention of relapse to opioid dependence, versus buprenorphine-naloxone (BUP-NX, Suboxone®), a high affinity partial agonist indicated for maintenance treatment of opioid dependence, as pharmacotherapeutic aids to recovery.

The study is conducted in 8 CTN-affiliated CTPs that provide or partner with detoxification services (inpatient/residential) which have the capacity to maintain participants opioid-free for approximately 3-7 days, have the capacity to provide medication-assisted therapy, and can provide a minimum of one group or individual counseling session per week during the 24-week treatment period. Up to 600 eligible participants will be randomized to treatment with XR-NTX or BUP-NX for 24 weeks (sufficient to include 350 participants who are randomized more than 72 hours after their last opioid). To maximize generalizability, the point of randomization is flexible, from shortly after program admission until just prior to program discharge. A data analysis modification (assessment of whether the early vs. late randomizers have a differential treatment effect and if so, time to relapse will be estimated for early and late randomizers separately) will occur if differential treatment initiation is a problem for cases randomized prior to completing detoxification (i.e., significantly fewer early randomizers are able to complete detoxification and XR-NTX induction).

The primary goal of the study is to estimate the difference, if one exists, between XR-NTX and BUP-NX in the distribution of the time to relapse (i.e., loss of persistent abstinence) during the 6-month trial. The primary outcome measure will be the time to the event, with the event called relapse. Secondary objectives are to: (1) compare outcome on XR-NTX versus BUP-NX across a range of clinical safety and secondary efficacy domains, and (2) explore demographic and, clinical, and genetic predictors of successful treatment and moderators of differential effectiveness (i.e., what variables may help clinicians choose which of these treatments is best for a given patient), and (3) collect a limited dataset to permit analyses of economic costs and benefits of the two treatments.

Toward the end of the 24-week treatment period, participants are referred for follow-up care in the community (which could include pharmacotherapy if desired and available), and follow-up outcomes are assessed at week 28 and week 36 after randomization. For participants receiving BUP-NX, who do not wish to continue, or for whom community resources are not available, the study provides a two-week BUP-NX taper.

In an ancillary genetics study we plan to study functional variants in three genes (OPRM1, OPRK1 and PDYN), known to affect the dynamic response to opioid receptor ligands. These variants will be evaluated in CTN-0051 for their contribution to treatment retention, abstinence, and depression. Blood collection for DNA extraction will occur at the same time that blood is collected for medical safety and liver function evaluation, precluding the need for an additional needle-stick. Coded blood samples for the genetics studies will be sent to the NIDA Center for Genetics Repository.

Who can participate

Healthy volunteers accepted: No

Only the study team can determine whether someone qualifies for participation.

Inclusion criteria

  • Male or female
  • 18 years of age and older
  • Meet DSM-5 criteria for opioid-use disorder (heroin and/or prescription opioids)
  • Have used opioids other than as specifically prescribed within thirty days prior to consent
  • Seeking treatment for opioid dependence and willing to accept "agonist-based" or "antagonist-based" therapy
  • In good-enough general health, as determined by the study physician on the basis of medical history, review of systems, physical exam and laboratory assessments, to permit treatment with XR-NTX or BUP-NX
  • Able to provide written informed consent
  • Able to speak English sufficiently to understand the study procedures and provide written informed consent to participate in the study
  • If female of childbearing potential, be willing to practice an effective method of birth control for the duration of participation in the study

Exclusion criteria

  • Serious medical, psychiatric or substance use disorder that, in the opinion of the study physician, would make study participation hazardous to the participant, or compromise study findings or would prevent the participant from completing the study. Examples include:
  • Disabling or terminal medical illness (e.g., uncompensated heart failure, cirrhosis or end-stage liver disease) as assessed by medical history, review of systems, physical exam and/or laboratory assessments;
  • Severe, untreated or inadequately treated mental disorder (e.g., active psychosis, uncontrolled manic-depressive illness) as assessed by history and/or clinical interview;
  • Current severe alcohol, benzodiazepine, or other depressant or sedative hypnotic use likely to require a complicated medical detoxification (routine alcohol and sedative detoxifications may be included)
  • LFTs (ALT, AST) greater than 5 times upper limit of normal
  • Suicidal or homicidal ideation that requires immediate attention
  • Known allergy or sensitivity to buprenorphine, naloxone, naltrexone, polylactide-co-glycolide, carboxymethylcellulose, or other components of the Vivitrol® diluent
  • Maintenance on methadone at doses of 30mg or greater at the time of signing consent
  • Presence of pain of sufficient severity as to require ongoing pain management with opioids
  • Pending legal action or other reasons that might prevent an individual from completing the study
  • If female, currently pregnant or breastfeeding, or planning on conception
  • Body habitus that, in the judgment of the study physician, precludes safe intramuscular injection of XR-NTX (e.g., BMI>40, excess fat tissue over the buttocks, emaciation)

Treatment and study plan

Extended-Release Naltrexone

Drug

Extended-Release Naltrexone (Vivitrol®)

Other names: Vivitrol®

Buprenorphine-Naloxone

Drug

Buprenorphine-Naloxone (Suboxone®)

Other names: Suboxone®

Primary outcomes

  1. Time to Relapse (Intent to Treat Population)

    Time frame: Weeks 3-24

    Relapse occurs if the participant is using any non-protocol prescribed opioids regularly starting at day 21 post-randomization or thereafter. Operationally, relapse is defined as either: (a) four consecutive opioid use weeks, or (b) seven consecutive days of use by self-report. A use week is defined as any week during which a participant self-reports at least one day of use during that week, provides a urine sample positive for non-protocol opioids, or fails to provide a urine sample. Self-report of opioid (heroin or prescription opioids) and other substance use is ascertained at each weekly study visit using the Timeline Follow-Back for each day leading back to the previous visit. Urine is collected at each study visit and tested for opioids. A missed UDS counts as a use week.

  2. Time to Relapse (Per Protocol Population)

    Time frame: Weeks 3-24

    Relapse occurs if the participant is using any non-protocol prescribed opioids regularly starting at day 21 post-randomization or thereafter. Operationally, relapse is defined as either: (a) four consecutive opioid use weeks, or (b) seven consecutive days of use by self-report. A use week is defined as any week during which a participant self-reports at least one day of use during that week, provides a urine sample positive for non-protocol opioids, or fails to provide a urine sample. Self-report of opioid (heroin or prescription opioids) and other substance use is ascertained at each weekly study visit using the Timeline Follow-Back for each day leading back to the previous visit. Urine is collected at each study visit and tested for opioids. A missed UDS counts as a use week.

Secondary outcomes

  1. Number Successfully Inducted Onto Assigned Study Medication

    Time frame: Weeks 0-24

    Binary Y/N assessment of whether the participant was or was not able to initiate their assigned study medication.

  2. Adverse Events Related to Study Medications

    Time frame: Weeks 0-36

    Adverse events reported by participants and assessed by clinical staff for relatedness to study medication. These determinations were reviewed by the study medical monitor.

  3. Opioid Abstinence Over Time While on Study Medication (Subjective)

    Time frame: Weeks 0-24

    Self report of opioid use by participants using the TLFB. At each visit, the TLFB was completed for dates going back to the last participant encounter.

  4. Alcohol Use Over Time, Drinks Per Day, Past 30 Days, W0

    Time frame: Week 0

    Alcohol use over time, drinks per day, past 30 days, at week 0

  5. Cigarette Smoking, W0, 10 or Less

    Time frame: Week 0

    Participants average cigarettes/day, in past 4 weeks, at week 0, equals 10 or less.

  6. Opioid Craving Over Time W0

    Time frame: Week 0

    Opioid craving over time via VAS at week 0

  7. Score of Subacute Withdrawal Symptoms Subscale Within Hamilton Depression (HAM-D) Rating Scale

    Time frame: Week 0

    The Subacute Withdrawal Symptoms Subscale consists of 6 symptoms. Classification of symptoms can be scored as: 0 - absent, 1 - doubtful or trivial, 2 - present. The total range of scores is 0 - 12, and the higher the total score the more severe the depression.

  8. Score of Alcohol Subscale Within Addiction Severity Index (ASI) Scale

    Time frame: Week 0

    The Alcohol Subscale within ASI is one question that asks how bothered one has been by alcohol problems. The total range of the subscale is 0-4. The higher the score, the bigger the problem.

  9. Score of Sexual Behavior Subscale Within HIV Risk-Taking Behavior Scale (HRBS)

    Time frame: Week 0

    The Sexual Behavior Subscale consists of 5 questions. Each question is scored from 0-5, for a total score range of 0-25. Higher scores indicate a greater degree of risk-taking behavior.

  10. Score on Trail Making Test Part A

    Time frame: Week 0

    Trail Making Test Part A consists of 25 circles distributed over a sheet of paper. The circles are number 1-25, and the patient is asked to draw lines to connect the numbers in ascending order. The patient is instructed to connect the circles as quickly as possible, without lifting the pen or pencil from the paper. Higher scores reveal greater impairment.

  11. Opioid Abstinence Over Time While on Study Medication (Objective)

    Time frame: Weeks 0-24

    A urine sample was obtained and tested for opioids at each in person visit; screening, prior to induction onto study medication, weekly through week 24 and at each of the follow up visits.

  12. Cigarette Smoking, W0 0

    Time frame: Week 0

    Participants average cigarettes/day, in past 4 weeks, at week 0, equals none

  13. Cigarette Smoking, W0 11-20

    Time frame: Week 0

    Participants average cigarettes/day, in past 4 weeks, at week 0, equals 11-20.

  14. Cigarette Smoking, W0 21-30

    Time frame: Week 0

    Participants average cigarettes/day, in past 4 weeks, at week 0, equals 21-30

  15. Cigarette Smoking, W0 31 or More

    Time frame: Week 0

    Participants average cigarettes/day, in past 4 weeks, at week 0, equals 31 or more

  16. Cigarette Smoking, W24 0

    Time frame: Week 24

    Participants average cigarettes/day, in past 4 weeks, at week 24, equals none

  17. Cigarette Smoking

    Time frame: Week 24

    Participants average cigarettes/day, in past 4 weeks, at week 24, equals 10 or less.

  18. Cigarette Smoking, W24 11-20

    Time frame: Week 24

    Participants average cigarettes/day, in past 4 weeks, at week 24, equals 11-20.

  19. Cigarette Smoking, W24 21-30

    Time frame: Week 24

    Participants average cigarettes/day, in past 4 weeks, at week 24, equals 21-30

  20. Cigarette Smoking, W24 31 or More

    Time frame: Week 24

    Participants average cigarettes/day, in past 4 weeks, at week 24, equals 31 or more

  21. Score on Opioid Craving Scale (OCS)

    Time frame: Week 24

    OCS is a brief 3-item measure used to measure opioid craving. The scale consists of 3 items rated on a visual analogue scale (VAS) from 1-10. The total range of score is 0-30, and a higher score indicates a stronger craver / desire to use opiates.

  22. Score of Subacute Withdrawal Symptoms Subscale Within Hamilton Depression (HAM-D) Rating Scale

    Time frame: Week 24

    The Subacute Withdrawal Symptoms Subscale consists of 6 symptoms. Classification of symptoms can be scored as: 0 - absent, 1 - doubtful or trivial, 2 - present. The total range of scores is 0 - 12, and the higher the total score the more severe the depression.

  23. Score on Subjective Opiate Withdrawal Scale (SOWS)

    Time frame: Week 0

    The SOWS is a self-administered scale for grading opioid withdrawal symptoms. It contains 16 symptoms whose intensity the patient rates on a scale of 0 (not at all) to 4 (extremely). The total range of scores is 0-64; the higher the score, the more intense the withdrawal.

  24. Score on Subjective Opiate Withdrawal Scale (SOWS)

    Time frame: Week 24

    The SOWS is a self-administered scale for grading opioid withdrawal symptoms. It contains 16 symptoms whose intensity the patient rates on a scale of 0 (not at all) to 4 (extremely). The total range of scores is 0-64; the higher the score, the more intense the withdrawal.

  25. Score of Sexual Behavior Subscale Within HIV Risk-Taking Behavior Scale (HRBS)

    Time frame: Week 24

    The Sexual Behavior Subscale consists of 5 questions. Each question is scored from 0-5, for a total score range of 0-25. Higher scores indicate a greater degree of risk-taking behavior.

  26. Score of Condom Use Subscale Within HIV Risk-Taking Behavior Scale (HRBS)

    Time frame: Week 0

    The Sexual Behavior Subscale consists of 3 questions. Each question is scored from 0-5, for a total score range of 0-15. Higher scores indicate a greater degree of risk-taking behavior.

  27. Score of Condom Use Subscale Within HIV Risk-Taking Behavior Scale (HRBS)

    Time frame: Week 24

    The Sexual Behavior Subscale consists of 3 questions. Each question is scored from 0-5, for a total score range of 0-15. Higher scores indicate a greater degree of risk-taking behavior.

  28. Score on Trail Making Test Part A

    Time frame: Week 24

    Trail Making Test Part A consists of 25 circles distributed over a sheet of paper. The circles are number 1-25, and the patient is asked to draw lines to connect the numbers in ascending order. The patient is instructed to connect the circles as quickly as possible, without lifting the pen or pencil from the paper. Higher scores reveal greater impairment.

  29. Score on Trail Making Test Part B

    Time frame: Week 0

    Part B consists of 25 circles distributed over a sheet of paper. In Part B, the circles include both numbers (1-13) and letters (A-L); the patient draws lines to connect the circles in an ascending pattern, by alternating between the numbers and letters. Results are reported as the number of seconds required to complete the task.

  30. Score on Trail Making Test Part B

    Time frame: Week 24

    Part B consists of 25 circles distributed over a sheet of paper. In Part B, the circles include both numbers (1-13) and letters (A-L); the patient draws lines to connect the circles in an ascending pattern, by alternating between the numbers and letters. Results are reported as the number of seconds required to complete the task.

  31. Score on Word Card of Stoop Test

    Time frame: Week 0

    The "word card" of the Stoop Test has the names of colors printed in black and white (100 items to be named). The patient's basic score is the total time he/she takes to utter the 100 words on the card.

  32. Score on Word Card of Stoop Test

    Time frame: Week 24

    The "word card" of the Stoop Test has the names of colors printed in black and white (100 items to be named). The patient's basic score is the total time he/she takes to utter the 100 words on the card.

  33. Score on Color Card of Stoop Test

    Time frame: Week 0

    The "color card" contains 100 patches of between 3-5 different colors. The patient's task is to utter the names of the colored patches as rapidly as possible, scanning the rows from left to right. The score is the total time (in seconds) it takes to utter the 100 colors.

  34. Score on Color Card of Stoop Test

    Time frame: Week 24

    The "color card" contains 100 patches of between 3-5 different colors. The patient's task is to utter the names of the colored patches as rapidly as possible, scanning the rows from left to right. The score is the total time (in seconds) it takes to utter the 100 colors.

  35. Score on Color Word Card of Stoop Test

    Time frame: Week 0

    The "color-word card" contains the printed names of colors, but printed in an ink of a conflicting color (e.g. the word RED might be printed in green, yellow, or blue). The patient is required to name the colors of the inks while ignoring the conflicting printed color names. The basic score is the total time (in seconds) to utter the 100 colors.

  36. Score on Color Word Card of Stoop Test

    Time frame: Week 24

    The "color-word card" contains the printed names of colors, but printed in an ink of a conflicting color (e.g. the word RED might be printed in green, yellow, or blue). The patient is required to name the colors of the inks while ignoring the conflicting printed color names. The basic score is the total time (in seconds) to utter the 100 colors.

  37. Score of Alcohol Subscale Within Addiction Severity Index (ASI) Scale

    Time frame: Week 24

    The Alcohol Subscale within ASI is one question that asks how bothered one has been by alcohol problems. The total range of the subscale is 0-4. The higher the score, the bigger the problem.

  38. Score of Drug Use Subscale Within Addiction Severity Index (ASI) Scale

    Time frame: Week 0

    The Drug Use Subscale within ASI is one question that asks how bothered one has been by drug use problems. The total range of the subscale is 0-4. The higher the score, the bigger the problem.

  39. Score of Drug Use Subscale Within Addiction Severity Index (ASI) Scale

    Time frame: Week 24

    The Drug Use Subscale within ASI is one question that asks how bothered one has been by drug use problems. The total range of the subscale is 0-4. The higher the score, the bigger the problem.

  40. Score of Social Relationship Subscale Within Addiction Severity Index (ASI) Scale

    Time frame: Week 0

    The Social Relationship Subscale within ASI contains 2 questions that ask how bothered one has been by family or social problems. The total range of the subscale is 0-8. The higher the score, the bigger the problem.

  41. Score of Family / Social Relationship Subscale Within Addiction Severity Index (ASI) Scale

    Time frame: Week 24

    The Family / Social Relationship Subscale within ASI contains 2 questions that ask how bothered one has been by family or social problems. The total range of the subscale is 0-8. The higher the score, the bigger the problem.

  42. Score of Legal Status Subscale Within Addiction Severity Index (ASI) Scale

    Time frame: Week 0

    The Legal Status Subscale within ASI is one question that asks how bothered one has been by legal problems. The total range of the subscale is 0-4. The higher the score, the bigger the problem.

  43. Score of Legal Status Subscale Within Addiction Severity Index (ASI) Scale

    Time frame: Week 24

    The Legal Status Subscale within ASI is one question that asks how bothered one has been by legal problems. The total range of the subscale is 0-4. The higher the score, the bigger the problem.

  44. Score of Medical Status Subscale Within Addiction Severity Index (ASI) Scale

    Time frame: Week 0

    The Medical Status Subscale within ASI is one question that asks how bothered one has been by medical problems. The total range of the subscale is 0-4. The higher the score, the bigger the problem.

  45. Score of Medical Status Subscale Within Addiction Severity Index (ASI) Scale

    Time frame: Week 24

    The Medical Status Subscale within ASI is one question that asks how bothered one has been by medical problems. The total range of the subscale is 0-4. The higher the score, the bigger the problem.

  46. Score of Psychiatric Status Subscale Within Addiction Severity Index (ASI) Scale

    Time frame: Week 0

    The Psychiatric Status Subscale within ASI is one question that asks how bothered one has been by psychiatric or emotional problems. The total range of the subscale is 0-4. The higher the score, the bigger the problem.

  47. Score of Psychiatric Status Subscale Within Addiction Severity Index (ASI) Scale

    Time frame: Week 24

    The Psychiatric Status Subscale within ASI is one question that asks how bothered one has been by psychiatric or emotional problems. The total range of the subscale is 0-4. The higher the score, the bigger the problem.

  48. Score on EuroQOL EQ-5D Questionnaire

    Time frame: Week 0

    Problems related to drug abuse is assessed through this questionnaire, which consists of 5 conditions. Each condition is scored from 0-2 for a total score range of 0-10. The higher the score, the more problems.

  49. Score on EuroQOL EQ-5D Questionnaire

    Time frame: Week 24

    Problems related to drug abuse is assessed through this questionnaire, which consists of 5 conditions. Each condition is scored from 0-2 for a total score range of 0-10. The higher the score, the more problems.

  50. Alcohol Use Over Time, Drinks Per Day

    Time frame: Week 24

    Alcohol use over time, drinks per day

  51. Other Drug Use Over Time, Cannabis, W0

    Time frame: week 0

    Other drug use over time measuring cannabis at week 0

  52. Other Drug Use Over Time, Cannabis, W24

    Time frame: week 24

    Other drug use over time measuring cannabis at week 24

  53. Other Drug Use Over Time, Cocaine, W0

    Time frame: week 0

    Other drug use over time measuring cocaine at week 0

  54. Other Drug Use Over Time, Cocaine, W24

    Time frame: week 24

    Other drug use over time measuring cocaine at week 0

  55. Other Drug Use Over Time, Stimulant, W0

    Time frame: week 0

    Other drug use over time measuring stimulant (cocaine, crack and amphetamine) at week 0

  56. Other Drug Use Over Time, Stimulant, W24

    Time frame: week 24

    Other drug use over time measuring stimulant (cocaine, crack and amphetamine) at week 24

Sponsors and collaborators

Lead sponsor

NYU Langone Health

Other

Collaborators

  • National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA)
  • The Emmes Company, LLC

Registry information

Official study title

CTN-0051: Extended-Release Naltrexone vs. Buprenorphine for Opioid Treatment

Important dates

Study start
2014
Primary completion
2017
Study completion
2017
First posted
Jan 10, 2014
Registry last updated
Aug 13, 2020

OpenTrials presents study information sourced from ClinicalTrials.gov. The official registry record should be consulted for the latest information.

View the official ClinicalTrials.gov record (opens in a new tab)

This listing is for discovery and informational purposes only. It is not medical advice, does not guarantee that a study is recruiting, and does not determine eligibility. Contact the study team and a qualified healthcare professional when considering participation.

Related clinical trials

Published trials that share one or more normalized conditions with this study.