Skip to main content
OpenTrials
Completed

NCT Number: NCT04275791

Assessment of the Benefit of an Inclusive Health Organization on the Prognosis of Severe Trauma Patients

Appropriate management reduces the mortality of severe trauma victims. This is based on a pre-hospital medical assessment of severity, the initiation of life-saving treatments at the pre-hospital level, and referral to a hospital with human and material resources adapted to the patient's severity. The objective of this research project is to show that the 28-day mortality after severe trauma is lower in a structured health system, compared to a non-structured system.

Completed

Looking for future studies?

Notify Me

Key information

Conditions

Wounds and Injuries

Age range

18 year and older

Sex eligibility

All sexes

Study type

Interventional

Phase

Not applicable

Primary location

Hôpital Pitié-Salpetrière

Paris, France

About this study

Appropriate management reduces the mortality of severe trauma victims defined by an Injury Severity Score (ISS) greater than 15 or the need for specialized and/or urgent treatment. This is based on a pre-hospital medical assessment of severity, the initiation of life-saving treatments at the pre-hospital level, and referral to a hospital with human and material resources adapted to the patient's severity.

The trauma hospital organisation in France is of the "exclusive" type. It contrasts trauma centres with other hospitals, only providing care for severe trauma victims in the former, which are most often confused with university hospitals. The choice of referral to this type of centre is made using a triage algorithm known as "de Vittel". In addition to an insufficient network within a region leading to longer hospital access time, this organisation leads to saturation of the referral centres by patients with few lesions. For this reason, this organisation has been rethought in an innovative way within the Auvergne-Rhône-Alpes region, in favour of an "inclusive" system that takes the form of a network of hospitals with capacities to receive severely traumatised patients that vary according to their equipment and personnel. Patients are referred within this network according to their severity category (unstable, stabilized or stable).

The main objective is to show that the 28-day mortality of severely traumatized persons oriented according to their severity in an inclusive system is lower, at identical severity, than in a conventional exclusive system in which the orientation is guided by the Vittel algorithm.

Secondary objectives are to show that the management of severe traumatized persons oriented according to their severity in an inclusive system, compared to the management in an exclusive conventional system in which the orientation is guided by the Vittel/ASCOTT algorithm, is associated, at identical severity, with :

  • Less under-triage;
  • Less over-triage;
  • A lower incidence of secondary transfers to a trauma center;
  • A greater number of days living without mechanical ventilation (during the first 28 days);
  • More days living without resuscitation (within the first 28 days);
  • More frequent and rapid use of whole-body CT scans with contrast injection;
  • More frequent and rapid use of specialized emergency therapies (laparotomy or hemostasis thoracotomy, embolization, craniectomy, intracranial pressure measurement, chest drainage).

Who can participate

Healthy volunteers accepted: No

Only the study team can determine whether someone qualifies for participation.

Inclusion criteria

  • Patients cared for in the aftermath of a severe trauma, by a pre-hospital medical team regulated by the territorially competent SAMU, who arrived at the hospital alive.

Exclusion criteria

  • Age < 18 years
  • Patients with no signs of life on hospital arrival and reported deceased within 30 minutes of admission
  • Patients with severe burns (>10% skin area burned)

Treatment and study plan

Triage

Other

Experimental : Trauma patient orientation in a structured regional health organization, composed of trauma centers hierarchized in several levels according to their capacity to receive severe traumatized persons.

Primary outcomes

  1. 28-day mortality

    Time frame: 28th day

    The primary endpoint will be 28-day mortality, defined as the occurrence of death from any cause within the first 28 days following trauma.

Secondary outcomes

  1. Undertriage

    Time frame: 28th day

    Undertriage, defined as the management outside the trauma care system adapted to their condition of patients whose ISS is strictly greater than 15, or presenting at least one of the following criteria:

    • the need for transfusion of more than 4 red blood cell concentrates during the first 6 hours of management;
    • the presence of severe head trauma with CT scan lesions;
    • the presence of a spinal cord injury;
    • the need for specialized emergency surgery (laparotomy or hemostasis thoracotomy, embolization, craniectomy, intracranial pressure measurement, chest drainage) within the first 24 hours;
    • the need for a secondary inter-hospital transfer to a trauma center. This variable will be assessed at the end of the 28th day, based on the data contained in the medical file and the administrative file.

  2. Over-triage

    Time frame: 28th day

    Over-triage, defined by the management of severely traumatized patients in the trauma centre and whose ISS is less than or equal to 15 and who do not present any of the following criteria :

    • the need for transfusion of more than 4 red blood cell concentrates during the first 6 hours of management;
    • the presence of severe head trauma with CT scan lesions;
    • the presence of a spinal cord injury;
    • the need for specialized emergency surgery (laparotomy or hemostasis thoracotomy, embolization, craniectomy, intracranial pressure measurement, chest drainage) within the first 24 hours;
    • the need for transfer to a trauma center. This variable will be evaluated at the end of the 28th day, based on the data contained in the medical file and in the administrative file

  3. Transfer to a trauma centre

    Time frame: 1 day

    Tranfer to a trauma centre at the end of the pre-hospital phase. This criterion will be evaluated at the time of admission of the patient out of the SMUR ambulance. Trauma centres are considered to be hospitals with a unit dedicated to the care of these patients, identified as such by the territorially competent regional health agency;

  4. Secondary inter-hospital transfer

    Time frame: 28th day

    The need for secondary inter-hospital transfer to a specialized trauma centre or a higher-level trauma centre. This variable is defined as the transfer of the patient, during the study period, from a hospital that does not have a trauma centre to the trauma centre of a hospital that does, or the transfer of the patient from a hospital trauma centre to a higher level trauma centre (III to II, II to I, III to I). This variable will be evaluated at the end of day 28, based on the data contained in the medical file and the administrative file. Transfers for specialized but non-urgent care (e.g. hand microsurgery that can be carried out beyond the first 24 hours) will not be counted as secondary inter-hospital transfers;

  5. Days living without mechanical ventilation

    Time frame: 28th day

    The number of days living without mechanical ventilation during the first 28 days. This criterion will be assessed at the end of the 28th day, by subtracting from 28 the number of days the patient received ventilatory support by mechanical ventilation. The change of day is made at midnight. By definition, deceased patients are assigned 0 days without mechanical ventilation;

  6. Days living without resuscitation

    Time frame: 28th day

    The number of days living without resuscitation during the first 28 days. This criterion will be assessed at the end of the 28th day, by subtracting from 28 the number of days the patient will have been in resuscitation. The change of day is made at midnight. By definition, deceased patients are assigned 0 days out of resuscitation;

  7. Length of stay in resuscitation

    Time frame: 28th day

    This variable will be evaluated at the end of the 28th day, based on the data contained in the medical record and in the administrative file;

  8. Modalities of the post-traumatic injury assessment by chest X-ray

    Time frame: first 24 hours of hospitalization

    This criterion will be assessed at the end of the first 24 hours of hospitalization. It will be assessed by first performing a chest X-ray

  9. Modalities of the post-traumatic injury assessment by pelvis X-ray

    Time frame: first 24 hours of hospitalization

    This criterion will be assessed at the end of the first 24 hours of hospitalization. It will be assessed by first performing a pelvis X-ray

  10. Modalities of the post-traumatic injury assessment by abdominal ultrasound

    Time frame: first 24 hours of hospitalization

    This criterion will be assessed at the end of the first 24 hours of hospitalization. It will be assessed by first performing an abdominal ultrasound

  11. Modalities of the post-traumatic injury assessment by transcranial Doppler scan

    Time frame: first 24 hours of hospitalization

    This criterion will be assessed at the end of the first 24 hours of hospitalization. It will be assessed by first performing a transcranial Doppler scan

  12. Modalities of the post-traumatic injury assessment by CT scan

    Time frame: first 24 hours of hospitalization

    This criterion will be assessed at the end of the first 24 hours of hospitalization. This evaluation will include a whole body CT scan with contrast media injection

  13. Modalities of the post-traumatic injury assessment by bone radiographs

    Time frame: first 24 hours of hospitalization

    This criterion will be assessed at the end of the first 24 hours of hospitalization. This evaluation will include guided bone radiographs;

  14. Need for and timing of laparotomy

    Time frame: 28th day

    The need for and timing of laparotomy within the first 24 hours. This variable will be evaluated at the end of the 28th day, based on the data contained in the medical file and in the administrative file;

  15. Need for and timing of hemostasis thoracotomy

    Time frame: 28th day

    The need for and timing of hemostasis thoracotomy within the first 24 hours. This variable will be evaluated at the end of the 28th day, based on the data contained in the medical file and in the administrative file;

  16. Need for and timing of embolization

    Time frame: 28th day

    The need for and timing of embolization within the first 24 hours. This variable will be evaluated at the end of the 28th day, based on the data contained in the medical file and in the administrative file;

  17. Need for and timing of craniectomy

    Time frame: 28th day

    The need for and timing of craniectomy within the first 24 hours. This variable will be evaluated at the end of the 28th day, based on the data contained in the medical file and in the administrative file;

  18. Need for and timing of intracranial pressure measurement

    Time frame: 28th day

    The need for and timing of intracranial pressure measurement within the first 24 hours. This variable will be evaluated at the end of the 28th day, based on the data contained in the medical file and in the administrative file;

  19. Need for and timing of chest drainage

    Time frame: 28th day

    The need for and timing of chest drainage within the first 24 hours. This variable will be evaluated at the end of the 28th day, based on the data contained in the medical file and in the administrative file;

  20. Distance to the nearest available pre-hospital medical facility

    Time frame: 1 day

    The distance to the nearest available pre-hospital medical facility. This variable is defined as the distance between the accident and the nearest available pre-hospital medical facility (light vehicles, mobile hospital units, helicopters) available at the time of the alert in the department concerned.

  21. Length of mechanical ventilation

    Time frame: 28th day

    This variable will be evaluated at the end of the 28th day, based on the data contained in the medical record and in the administrative file;

  22. Length of hospital stay

    Time frame: 28th day

    This variable will be evaluated at the end of the 28th day, based on the data contained in the medical record and in the administrative file;

Sponsors and collaborators

Lead sponsor

Assistance Publique - Hôpitaux de Paris

Other

Registry information

Acronym: TRAUMINXCLUSIF

Important dates

Study start
2022
Primary completion
2023
Study completion
2024
First posted
Feb 19, 2020
Registry last updated
Mar 10, 2026

OpenTrials presents study information sourced from ClinicalTrials.gov. The official registry record should be consulted for the latest information.

View the official ClinicalTrials.gov record (opens in a new tab)

This listing is for discovery and informational purposes only. It is not medical advice, does not guarantee that a study is recruiting, and does not determine eligibility. Contact the study team and a qualified healthcare professional when considering participation.

Related clinical trials

Published trials that share one or more normalized conditions with this study.