Randomized Clinical Trial of Rehabilitation for Subacromial Impingement Syndrome

Subacromial impingement syndrome (SAIS) is a frequent cause of shoulder pain. Clinical trials investigating the effectiveness of manual therapy have demonstrated improvements in outcomes when manual therapy has been added to a program of therapeutic exercise. However, the these clinical trials (3) have significant limitations and generalizability. Two of the three 3 trials had a small number of subjects (14 & 22 subjects) and all 3 trials had only short term follow up (<12 weeks) and used non-validated self report outcome measures. These limitations reduce the confidence with which clinicians can apply these results to the patients they treat with SAIS. Clear evidence is needed to justify the cost and clinician time required to perform manual therapy in the delivery of patient care. Therefore, the purpose of this randomized clinical trial is to examine the short-term and long-term effectiveness of manual therapy in addition to therapeutic exercise as compared to therapeutic exercise only in patients diagnosed with SAIS.

Inclusion criteria

• Symptoms associated with athletic activity (35% of patients)
• Diagnosis of shoulder impingement syndrome as evidence by all 3 criteria:

• Reproduction of symptoms with impingement test: either Hawkins- Kennedy or Neer Test
• Pain during active shoulder elevation at or above 60 degrees
• Weakness of rotator cuff or pain during the Empty Can test or during resisted shoulder external rotation
• Shoulder disability: 25/100 (0 = no disability)
• Able to understand written and spoken

Exclusion criteria

• Severe pain; pain is > 7/10 on NPRS (0 = no pain)
• Shoulder surgery on affected shoulder
• Traumatic shoulder dislocation within the past 3 months
• Previous rehabilitation for this episode of shoulder pain
• Reproduction of shoulder pain with active or passive cervical motion
• Systemic inflammatory joint disease
• Global loss of passive shoulder ROM, indicative of adhesive capsulitis
• Full-thickness rotator cuff tear, as evidenced by any one of the following:

• Markedly reduced shoulder external rotation strength
• Drop arm test
• External rotation lag sign
• Lift off test
• Positive findings on MRI or ultrasonography