NAOMI: A Study to Compare Medically-prescribed Heroin With Oral Methadone in Chronic Opiate Addiction

This is a two-centre (Vancouver, Montreal) RCT involving a total of 235 volunteers. Eligible participants will be randomized to injectable heroin combined with oral methadone as desired (45%) versus oral methadone alone (45%). A subset of 10% will be randomized to injectable hydromorphone (Dilaudid™). Hydromorphone and heroin will be given in a double-blind fashion; the purpose is to permit validation of reported illicit use of heroin through urine testing in the hydromorphone group. Research visits will be conducted quarterly and will occur independently of treatment clinic visits. Incentives will be used to maintain research follow-up whether or not the subject is retained in treatment. The analysis will be under intent-to-treat. The primary outcomes of interest are 1) recruitment and retention in the study and 2) illicit drug use and criminal behavior (as determined by the Europ-ASI) at 12 months. Secondary outcomes are measures of social function (e.g., social integration and functioning, quality of life) and cost-benefit/effectiveness of the interventions.

Inclusion criteria

• Opioid Dependence as confirmed by DSM-IV diagnostic criteria
• 25 years of age or older
• 5 years or more of opioid use
• Regular opioid injection use in the past month and in at least 8 months in the past 12 months (self reported; regular use - defined as injecting opioids for at least 4 days or more in a week); 50% or more of the injections during the prior year must have involved heroin).
• Minimum of one-year residence in site/city location
• No enrollment in any other opioid substitution (e.g. methadone) program within the prior 6 months - enrollment is defined as having received at least 45 milligrams of prescribed methadone per day on any 30 consecutive days or more in the prior 6 months
• At least two previous episodes of opiate addiction treatment (methadone maintenance, detoxification, residential care, etc) during which, on at least one occasion, the patient received at least 60 mg of methadone daily for at least 30 days in a 40 day period
• Willingness and ability to adhere to study protocol and follow-up schedule as determined through the three-week pre-randomization period (see Section C.4)
• Documentation of fulfillment of the above study criteria (prison records, treatment records, cohort study enrollment, urine sampling)
• Provide written and informed consent.

Exclusion criteria

• Diagnosis of severe medical or psychiatric conditions that are contra-indicated for heroin treatment
• Pregnancy upon study entry
• On parole or with current justice system involvement that is likely to result in an extended period of incarceration (more than 4 months) during the study period (e.g. scheduled trial for an indictable offense, jail, etc)
• Hydromorphone is a class C teratogen and should not be given to pregnant women. All female subjects upon study entry will be urged to engage only in protected sexual intercourse and will provide consent to undergo monthly pregnancy tests during the course of the study.
• Serum bilirubin >2.5 x normal
• Stage II or greater hepatic encephalopathy
• Chronic respiratory disease resulting in resting respiratory rate >20/minute
• Bipolar Mood Disorder, Schizophrenia or other psychotic disorder with active psychotic symptoms within the past 6 months
• Major Depression refractory to medical management or requiring electroconvulsive therapy within the past 12 months.