Home-Based Leg Dexterity Trainer for Management of Knee Osteoarthritis

The investigators will conduct a randomized home-based clinical trial in knee OA to demonstrate the efficacy of leg dexterity training to reduce pain and improve function compared to currently prescribed dynamic exercise on a wobble board (a commonly used approach for improving proprioception and balance). Successful completion of this study will justify the adoption of the Leg Dexterity System as an effective at-home supplement to any nonsurgical management of knee OA.

The investigators propose a longitudinal double-blind dose-matched trial comparing 8 weeks of leg dexterity training (Treatment using a slender, unstable spring system that engages short-latency sensorimotor control, 42 participants) vs. at-home wobble board exercises (Control, 42 participants) at the Steadman Philippon Research Institute.

Primary Hypothesis: Neuromuscular control: Compared to the Control group, the Treatment group will report greater reduction in knee pain and demonstrate improved function in the more-affected leg. The primary outcomes measures will include The Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Arthritis Index (WOMAC) Pain subscale and the Single Limb Stance Test (SLS).

Secondary Hypothesis: Whole-body function: Compared to the Control group, greater OA-related whole-body functional improvements will be found in the Treatment group. Secondary outcome measures include the WOMAC stiffness and physical function subscales; International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) Subjective Knee score, Timed-up-and-go test (TUG); 6 min walk test (6MW); 40-meter walk (40mW) Test; and lower-extremity Gait analysis.

The Leg Dexterity System:

To use the Leg Dexterity system, seated individuals are instructed to use a single leg to slowly compress the spring with the platform with the goal to make the force feedback line as high as possible (i.e., maximize vertical compression force) throughout each ~10 second trial without letting the foot slip on the platform (see Figure). The spring begins to show instabilities at low forces. Participants are informed that it is ok for the spring to bend and oscillate (i.e., due to the instability inherent in task). Despite the motion, the goal is to maintain the highest possible force level without the spring buckling (which occurs when the force exceeds 15% of body weight). Because the spring becomes increasingly instable even at these low forces, the maximal sustained compression quantifies their maximal neuromuscular control abilities.

The Wobble Board:

Commercial wobble boards (Core-Tex Reactive Trainer, Core-Tex Fitness, Inc. shown at right). are an intervention used at home and the clinic to improve leg and body dynamic control. As shown, the wobble board is equipped with safety bars to protect against falls and poses minimal risk for older adults and adults with knee OA. To use the wobble board with eyes open, participants will stand on the center of the board and perform 5 repetitions each of: (i) forward/backward and (ii) side-to-side board tilts, and 30 seconds of (iv) single-leg stance on each leg. This wobbleboard protocol is a safe and effective intervention in knee OA[67,68], and participants are encouraged to minimize the use of the handle bars within their comfort level to maximize and improve leg and body dynamic control.

Participant Assignment:

After informed consent, study participants will undergo a baseline assessment and be randomized to receive either the Leg Dexterity device or the wobbleboard. They will then take their assigned device home, with instructions to perform the exercises they were trained on 3 times per week for 8 weeks and maintain a log of their activities. After 8 weeks, they will return to the Steadman Philippon Research Institute for a repeat assessment and to return the equipment.

Establish the clinical feasibility, utility and efficacy of using a home-based Leg Dexterity training program to reduce pain and improve function for individuals with osteoarthritis.

There is a single endpoint at 8 weeks after initiation of training.

• 82 patient participants with knee osteoarthritis, targeting equal numbers of male and female participants.

This is a Phase II clinical trial, providing an initial assessment of efficacy.

Single-center study conducted at the Steadman Philippon Research Institute in Vail, CO

Participants will be randomized into one of two home treatment regimens, utilizing either the Leg Dexterity system or a commercially available wobbleboard. Training will occur 3 times per week for 8 weeks.

36 months

The initial visit will consist of informed consent, screening, baseline testing and training on the proper use of either the Knee Dexterity system or the wobbleboard. This visit will take approximately 3 hours. Participants will then conduct 8 weeks of home-based training using their assigned device. They will then return for their follow-up visit, during which the assessments performed at baseline will be repeated. This visit will take approximately 90 minutes. The supplied training device will be returned and study participation will be complete. Total study duration for each participant will be approximately 10 weeks.

Inclusion criteria

• Age 40 to 85 years
• Ambulatory in home and community settings
• History of knee osteoarthritis in one or both knees (Kellgren-Lawrence grade II-IV)
• Baseline pain of 3-10 points on the target (i.e., more-affected) knee and a pain differential of at least -2 points on the contralateral knee as exhibited by the worst pain score for the previous week (on the 11-point Numeric Rating Scale, NRS/Visual Analog Scale VAS).
• Capacity to personally give informed consent (consent via a legally authorized representative will not be accepted) and who are willing to comply with all study-related procedures and assessments

Exclusion criteria

• Previous or Planned Knee Surgeries, Procedures, and/or Treatments:

• Planned surgery on either the contralateral or target knee at any time during the Study period, including pre-and post-training assessments.
• Within 6 months of signing informed consent has received diagnostic arthroscopy of the target knee or arthroscopic surgery (including microfracture and meniscectomy) on the target knee;
• Within 12 weeks of signing informed consent has received intra-articular treatment of the target knee with steroids or hyaluronic acid derivatives;
• Planned intra-articular treatment of the target knee with steroids or hyaluronic acid derivatives on either the contralateral or target knee at any time during the Study period including pre-and post-training assessments.
• History of previous total or partial arthroplasty in the target knee. Partial or total arthroplasty in the contralateral knee is acceptable as long as the surgery was performed at least 6 months prior to enrollment and the operative knee is asymptomatic
• Current and/or Previous Medical Conditions, Surgeries, and/or Procedures:

• Within 2 years of signing informed consent, history of active blood disorders (i.e., DVTs, chronic blood clotting, hemophilia, leukemia, myeloma, etc.); or active malignancy of any type or history of a malignancy (with the exception of subjects with a history of treated basal or squamous cell carcinoma).
• Current diagnosis of fibromyalgia based on American College of Rheumatology (ACR) criteria.
• Any active known or suspected systemic autoimmune disease (except for vitiligo, residual auto-immune hypothyroidism requiring hormone replacement only, psoriasis not requiring systemic treatment for two years, conditions not expected to recur in the absence of an external trigger) or any history of systemic inflammatory arthritis such as psoriatic, rheumatoid, ankylosing spondylitis or reactive arthritis.
• Current or prior history of other joint diseases including but not limited to joint dysplasia, crystal-induced arthropathy (such as gout, or calcium pyrophosphate deposition disease evidenced by clinical and/or radiographic means), aseptic osteonecrosis, acromegaly, Paget's disease, Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome, Gaucher's disease, Stickler syndrome, joint infection, hemochromatosis, or neuropathic arthropathy of any cause.
• Any medical condition, including findings in laboratory or medical history or in the baseline assessments, that (in the opinion of the Principal Investigator or his designee) constitutes a risk or contraindication for participation in the Study or that could interfere with the Study conduct, endpoint evaluation or prevent the subject from fully participating in all aspects of the Study.
• Within 8 weeks of signing informed consent, has used opioid analgesics and is not willing to discontinue these medications through the duration of the study.