Farming, Personal Protective Equipment, Nepal

LITERATURE SEARCH STRATEGY:

Based on recommendations from information specialists in the field of health, agriculture and technology the following databases were chosen to search for scientific literature about the present study's purpose: Pubmed, Embase, SveMed, CAB abstracts (Centre for Agriculture and Biosciences International), Agris, DADS (Denmark's Technical University's Digital Library), Scopus and Ebsco. The key search terms for the literature search were: personal protective equipment, farmers, pesticides, developing countries and tropical climate. Synonyms for each of these search terms were identified by means of Gyldendals Dictionary and previous international literature. In Pubmed, SveMed, Embase, CAB abstracts and Agris the synonyms were applied to find subject headings which the main search was based on. However, in DADS, Scopus, Ebsco searches on subject headings was not an option and therefore the main search was based on the synonyms.

• Pubmed: 3349 hits, subject headings for key terms personal protective equipment and pesticides with no limitations.
• Embase: 399 hits, subject headings for key terms personal protective equipment and pesticides with the limitation human.
• SveMed: 24 hits, subject headings for key terms personal protective equipment and pesticides.
• CAB abstracts: 607 hits, subject headings for key terms personal protective equipment and pesticides.
• Agris: 681 hits, subject headings for key terms personal protective equipment and pesticides.
• DADS 8650 hits, subject headings for key terms personal protective equipment and pesticides.
• Scopus: 1988 hits, synonyms for key terms personal protective equipment and pesticides and developing countries and tropical climate with the limitation to human.
• EBSCO: 722 hits, synonyms for key terms personal protective equipment and pesticides.

Firstly, the relevance of titles was evaluated, secondly the relevance of abstracts from hits with relevant titles was evaluated and thirdly the relevance of full texts from hits with relevant abstracts was evaluated. A search was made based on the function 'related studies' for each relevant study in each database. The reference list of each relevant study was viewed and searched in Web of Science for citations. Finally each accessible relevant study was read carefully (5 hits). Exclusion criteria were studies on closed farming, mechanized farming, non-tropical conditions, and farming in industrialized countries or laboratory performance testing of personal protective equipment seeing that these criteria would not represent typical farming conditions in developing countries. Grey literature was searched in databases of the International Labor Organization, World Health Organization and Food and Agricultural Organization.

STUDY AREA:

Nepal is divided into 75 administrative districts. Pesticide consumption data show that excessive use of pesticides is common in different crops such as rice, maize, wheat and vegetables production areas. Chitwan District is selected purposively for three reasons:

• One of the highest vegetable growing districts of Nepal is Chitwan.
• An excessive pesticide use is documented in Chitwan.
• An unpublished study being the first of its kind in Nepal known to the research group documents the seriousness of the problem in Chitwan. A comparative cross-sectional study was conducted among 90 vegetable farmers using hand pressured backpack sprayers and 90 blood donors. Fifty %, 15 % and 13 % of the pesticides used by the vegetable farmers could be categorized as moderately, highly and slightly hazardous, respectively, according to the World Health Organization Hazard Classification. Organophosphates were one of the most common pesticides used by the vegetable farmers; the moderately hazardous chlorpyrifos and imidacloprid as well as the highly hazardous dichlorvos. Poor working practices without adequate safety precautions were common among the vegetable farmers. The vegetable farmers reported a higher number of acute organophosphate poisoning symptoms and had lower levels of acetyl cholinesterase than blood donors. Chitwan has a total population of around 566,661 and was a largely uncultivated dense forest before the Nepali government started spraying with the insecticide dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane for a Malaria Eradication Project in the 1950s. Immediately, Chitwan became a major farming region and services and infrastructure expanded across the area. Out of a total 46,894 hectare of arable land, 44,291 hectare is used for agricultural purpose (maize, rice, wheat, beans, lentils, mustard and vegetables). Agriculture is the primary source of income for 75 % of the population. Around 4000-5000 people of the working population is engaged in vegetable farming. Chitwan has 40 village district committees and the District Agricultural Office considers 10 of these as pocket areas in terms of vegetable farming based on their own observations, experiments, monitoring and personal communication with vegetable farmers. The ten pocket areas are Mangalpur, Jagatpur, Shukranagar, Chainpur, Bhandara, Gitanagar, Sibanagar, Jutpani, Kumroj and Padampur. To the extent that it is possible farmers fulfilling the inclusion and exclusion criteria of the present study in these pocket areas will be recruited:

RECRUITMENT STRATEGY:

Non-probability.

SAMPLE SIZE DETERMINATION:

The sample size calculations are based on a quasi-experimental unpublished study of 25 vegetable farmers from Chitwan whose acute organophosphate poisoning symptoms and plasma cholinesterase levels were measured pre and post an organophosphate spraying session on the same day during daily practice conditions.

• Mean number of acute organophosphate poisoning symptoms 1.08±1.32 (Pre spraying measurement) 2.4±1.87 (Post spraying measurement) 0.0003 (P-value)
• Mean U/ml level of plasma cholinesterase 1.41±0.59 (Pre spraying measurement) 1.29±0.54 (Post spraying measurement) 0.0548 (P-value)

The pre and post organophosphate spraying measurements are considered to represent the "healthiest" and "unhealthiest" condition that the vegetable farmers can be expected to be in, respectively. Thus, for the present study the pre and post organophosphate spraying measurements are expected to resemble the results among the farmers after having worked with organophosphates wearing the LAPPE solution and DP solution, respectively. A sample size suitable to the study resources was gained when applying the pre and post results of the number of acute organophosphate poisoning symptoms.

• Paired means = 1.08, 2.4
• Paired standard deviations = 1.320,1.870
• Correlation = 0
• Sides = 1, 2
• Alpha = 0.05
• Power = 0.9

Taking into consideration dropouts, technical problems leading to invalid measurements, refusals and co-variables for multivariate analyses 33 % of the sample size (34 pairs) is added, the result being rounded up to 50 pairs of farmers needed for the present study.

DATA ANALYSES:

Descriptive:

• Frequency, proportion categorical variables
• Mean, minimum, maximum and standard deviation of numeric variables
• Table crossing background, explanatory and feasibility variables with LAPPE/DP experiment
• Table crossing number of acute organophosphate poisoning symptoms with plasma cholinesterase levels U/ml

Unadjusted (paired t-test and McNemar test):

• Mean difference in number of acute organophosphate poisoning symptoms after both experiments
• Mean difference in plasma cholinesterase level U/ml after both experiments

Adjusted (mixed model):

• Number of acute organophosphate poisoning symptoms after the LAPPE experiment is compared to the number of acute organophosphate poisoning symptoms after the DP experiment adjusted for baseline values, period effect, experiment sequence and explanatory variables.
• Plasma cholinesterase level U/ml after the LAPPE experiment is compared to the plasma cholinesterase level U/ml after the DP experiment adjusted for baseline values, period effect, experiment sequence and explanatory variables.

Sensitivity:

To allow confidence in the main finding its robustness will be assessed by repeating the analyses with more rigid health outcome definitions if possible such as:

• Farmers with acute organophosphate poisoning symptoms before the LAPPE and DP experiment are excluded.
• Farmers with more abnormal plasma cholinesterase levels U/ml before the LAPPE and DP experiment are excluded.
• Farmers with chronic illness are excluded.
• Farmers who respond to the "fake" symptoms are excluded.

ETHICAL CONSIDERATIONS:

Informal recognition and encouragement in Chitwan will be obtained from the District Agricultural Office and District Public Health Office. An advisory opinion from the Danish Ethics Committee will be obtained. Informed consents will be retrieved from farmers participating in the pre-testing and experiments.

The plasma cholinesterase measurement will make it possible to identify farmers with abnormal levels. If such cases occur the farmer will be excluded from the study and given advice on how to proceed. The small amount of blood required is not considered as damaging to the farmers' health. However, the finger stick may have minor risks such as momentary pain when the lancet goes into the finger, bruise, visible and sore puncture site for a short period, feeling of dizziness or light headedness. Disposable finger stick lancets will be used to avoid any infectious transmission.

The LAPPE solution will be provided to the farmers after their participation with an information folder and oral explanation on how to store the LAPPE. Despite the results of the study, the LAPPE solution is an improvement in farmers' current practice which is that they basically do not protect themselves according to the recommendations of World Health Organization or Food and Agricultural Organization.

The choice of organophosphates for the experiments will be based on the type of organophosphates that the farmers already use. In other words, the farmers will not be exposed to less or more dangerous pesticides than what they usually expose themselves to. During the data collection the organophosphates will be stored according to their safety label recommendations. In case, the remaining organophosphates cannot be used in other studies they will be disposed by taking safety precautions as recommended by the World Health Organization.

During all study activities a first aid kit will be accessible and the data collectors will wear basic personal protective equipment during the experiments and informed about a safe handling of organophosphates.

During data entry, data is stored on two external hard disks and the principal investigator's computer in the control of the principal investigator. Data on the Test Mate ChE Cholinesterase System is automatically deleted when the power is switched off. Every week a full backup of the data file will be saved on a USB stick placed outside research establishments under the principal investigator's control until the data entry is complete. Data editing and analysis will be based on a data file without sensitive information (like name, address and phone number). The data file will be saved on an external hard disk, USB stick and the principal investigator's computer drop box on a daily basis and kept under secure conditions and with only access to the principal investigator.

The following data will be stored in a locked safe under research establishments in the sole control of the principal investigator:

• Original data
• File with raw data
• File with analyzable and anonymized data
• File linking farmers' sensitive information with their study identification number

The following data will be stored in a locked safe outside research establishments in the sole control of the principal investigator and safe owners:

• File with analyzable data excluding sensitive information

If necessary, during analysis and interpretation of results the research group can get access to the file with analyzable and anonymized data through e-mail. However, the e-mail will not contain the file linking sensitive information with study identification numbers and is therefore considered as being manually encrypted.

Upon completion of the research study the original data will be cut into pieces, placed in a sealable bag which can be tightly tied, fill the bag with water and then transfer the bag to a waste container. Blood tests and materials used in this regard will be given to Nepal Red Cross Society. Data stored outside research establishments will be retrieved. Two independent data files; one file with analyzable data excluding sensitive information and another file with farmers' sensitive information linking to their study identification number and scanned copies of informed consents will be stored in Nepal for up to five years. Potential permission to store data in Denmark will be seeked from the Danish Data Protection Agency. Upon approval data will be sent to the Danish Data Archive for indefinite storage time with data documentation. The condition for data access to the Danish Data Archive is that only the principal investigator will have access to the data and full control of giving permission for sharing data with others in the future. If sharing of data occurs the new researcher will have to seek approval from the Danish Data Protection Agency and then consult the Danish Data Archive.

Inclusion

• Male (females usually wear national dresses considered to provide adequate protection (43).
• Age min. 18 years (implies being a legal worker).
• Grows crops in knee and abdomen height in given data collection period.
• Willing to spend 1.5-3 hours working with organophosphates under normal working conditions.
• Involved in farming minimum two years (implies being active).
• Usually sprays at least once in two weeks with organophosphates on average (implies being active).
• Uses a hand pressured backpack sprayer placed at home (necessary to complete non-intervention).
• Works with crops in 5-10 katha land (sufficient to apply organophosphates for given time).
• Has a mobile/landline number (necessary for easy contact).

Exclusion

• Has a helper during work with organophosphates (organophosphate exposure reduced).
• Is unwilling to stay organophosphate free one week prior to each of two experiment days (necessary for comparable measurements).
• Has any of the following conditions: liver disease/damage, alcoholic/viral hepatitis, acute infection, chronic malnutrition, heart attack, metastasis, obstructive jaundice, inflammation, uses pyridostigmine drugs (decreases or increases plasma cholinesterase) (44-46).