Skip to main content
OpenTrials
Completed

NCT Number: NCT03815162

Cocoa Flavanol Supplementation in Raynaud's Phenomenon

The study aims to investigate the effect that supplementing the diet with cocoa flavanols has on vasospasm symptoms and temperature regulation in women with primary Raynaud's phenomenon (PRP). Participants will be randomised to consume either high flavanol cocoa extract or low flavanol cocoa (placebo) daily for 3 months.

Completed

Looking for future studies?

Notify Me

Key information

Age range

18 year–60 year

Sex eligibility

All sexes

Study type

Interventional

Phase

Not applicable

Primary location

David Greenfield Human Physiology Laboratories

Nottingham, Notts, NG72UH, United Kingdom

About this study

Primary Raynaud's phenomenon (PRP) is characterised by periodic vasospasm of the fingers and toes precipitated by exposure to cold or emotional stimuli and stress. Previous studies have demonstrated that underlying this condition there can be vascular endothelium dysfunction. Pharmacological interventions used to relieve symptoms and complications in PRP include drugs targeted at increasing nitric oxide (NO; transdermal nitrates) levels. Cocoa derived products, rich in the phytonutrients 'flavanols', have been shown to increase the bioavailability of NO at the vascular endothelium and promote vasodilation, which may address an underlying cause of PRP and mitigate symptoms. Previous work carried out in the research group has indicated that the acute consumption of cocoa does not compromise the counter-regulatory responses to localised cold exposure in those with PRP.

30 individuals with PRP will be recruited. Those interested in taking part will attend a medical screening and consent visit. If recruited, a participant number will be assigned to them sequentially and they will be randomised to either experimental or control group, with neither the participants nor the research team knowing which group they have been allocated to. Participants will be asked to complete a diet diary before attending 4 further visits over a period of 3 months.

Visit 1 (pre-intervention) and 4 (end of intervention); immediately on arrival, participants will be asked to lie semi-supine on a hospital bed. Skin temperature (surface thermocouples) and 'core' temperature (infrared tympanic thermometer) will start to be recorded to identify when these parameters have stabilized in room temperature (set at 25oC). Blood pressure will be taken using an arm cuff. Then a Finometer cuff will be attached to the left middle finger to record cardiovascular parameters (Blood pressure /heart rate/ cardiac output) and a laser Doppler probe will be attached to the dorsum of both index fingers to assess skin blood flow. Once the finger skin temperature has remained stable for 6 minutes, baseline Finometer and laser Doppler measurements will be recorded and the skin and 'core' temperature will be noted. Then, the right hand will be placed in a temperature regulated box which is set at an air temperature of 0oC. The hand will be cooled to a finger skin temperature of 15oC, then the box temperature will be modified to maintain the skin temperature at 15oC. The time that it takes for the skin temperature on the fingers to reach 15oC will be recorded. With the finger skin temperature stable at 15oC, Finometer and laser Doppler measurements will be repeated and the 'core' temperature at this point noted. Then, the hand will be removed from the chamber, and allowed to equilibrate in room temperature. The time taken for the skin temperature to reach stability will be recorded, as will the absolute temperature that it stabilises to. Measures above will be repeated once hand temperature is stable. Once these measures have been made, all equipment will be removed and a 15ml blood sample will be taken (for epicatechin, glucose and insulin analysis). The participant will be asked to complete 3 questionnaires (SF-36, Raynaud's symptoms and a food frequency questionnaire). Participants will also return a 4-day diet diary at visits 1 and 4, and their symptom diary at visit 4.

Visits 2 (end of month 1) and 3 (end of month 2); participants will return a 4-day diet diary, symptom diary and any unused capsules. They will also have a resting blood pressure measurement made, weight measured and be asked to complete 3 questionnaires (SF-36, Raynaud's symptoms and a food frequency questionnaire).

At the end of Visits 1, 2 and 3, participants will be given a months' supply of capsules, a symptom diary and a diet diary (to be completed in the week prior to the next visit).

Who can participate

Healthy volunteers accepted: Yes

Only the study team can determine whether someone qualifies for participation.

Inclusion criteria

  • Experience symptoms of Primary Raynaud's Phenomenon, with >1 attack / week through the winter months
  • Daily consumption of caffeine containing foods/drinks.
  • BMI <27kg/m2

Exclusion criteria

  • pregnant or breast feeding (women only),
  • clinically significant metabolic or endocrine abnormalities
  • fasting glucose >6.5mmol/l,
  • taking Bosentan, aspirin, dipyridamole, heparin or transdermal nitrates,
  • herbal supplement use,
  • food allergies related to the investigational product (cocoa, peanuts, milk),
  • sensitivity to methylxanthines (e.g. caffeine, theobromine).
  • Presence or history of digital ulceration,
  • blood parameters suggesting secondary Raynaud's,
  • history of migraines

Treatment and study plan

High Flavanol Cocoa extract

Dietary Supplement

Experimental group

Alkalised cocoa

Dietary Supplement

Control group

Primary outcomes

  1. Vasospasm

    Time frame: 3 months

    frequency of vasospasm

Secondary outcomes

  1. Severity of vasospasm symptoms

    Time frame: 3 months

    visual analogue score for pain associated with each vasospasm occasion. Participants indicate pain intensity by placing a vertical line on a 100mm horizontal line where the start of the line (left-hand side; 0mm) represents 'no pain' and the end of the line (right-hand side; 100mm) represents 'most severe pain'. Distance of the vertical line from 0 provides the visual analogue score. A lower score indicates a more favourable outcome.

  2. Duration of vasospasm symptoms

    Time frame: 3 months

    duration that symptoms persist for on each vasospasm occasion

  3. Raynaud's Condition score

    Time frame: 3 months

    Assessment of Raynaud's symptoms using the validated Raynaud's Condition Score. This is a 1 to 10 Likert scale, with 0 representing 'no difficulty' and 10 indicating 'extreme difficulty' with symptoms; collected daily for 3 months, a lower score indicates a more favourable outcome.

  4. Blood pressure

    Time frame: pre-intervention

    blood pressure measured by automated oscillometric blood pressure

  5. Blood pressure

    Time frame: 4 weeks after starting intervention

    blood pressure measured by automated oscillometric blood pressure

  6. Blood pressure

    Time frame: 8 weeks after starting intervention

    blood pressure measured by automated oscillometric blood pressure

  7. Blood pressure

    Time frame: 12 weeks after starting the intervention

    blood pressure measured by automated oscillometric blood pressure

  8. Dietary polyphenol intake

    Time frame: pre-intervention

    estimation of dietary polyphenols made by food frequency questionnaire

  9. Dietary polyphenol intake

    Time frame: 4 weeks after starting intervention

    estimation of dietary polyphenols made by food frequency questionnaire

  10. Dietary polyphenol intake

    Time frame: 8 weeks after starting intervention

    estimation of dietary polyphenols made by food frequency questionnaire

  11. Dietary polyphenol intake

    Time frame: 12 weeks after starting the intervention

    estimation of dietary polyphenols made by food frequency questionnaire

  12. Ambient skin temperature

    Time frame: pre-intervention

    skin temperature of a finger exposed to an environmental temperature of 25oC, before cooling

  13. Ambient skin temperature

    Time frame: 12 weeks after starting the intervention

    skin temperature of a finger exposed to an environmental temperature of 25oC, before cooling

  14. Ambient skin blood flow

    Time frame: pre-intervention

    finger blood flow (measured using laser Doppler flowmetry) when exposed to an environmental temperature of 25oC, before cooling

  15. Ambient skin blood flow

    Time frame: 12 weeks after starting the intervention

    finger blood flow (measured using laser Doppler flowmetry) when exposed to an environmental temperature of 25oC, before cooling

  16. Skin temperature response to acute cooling

    Time frame: pre-intervention

    The time taken for skin temperature of the finger to stabilise in response to localised cooling (in an air temperature of 0oC)

  17. Skin temperature response to acute cooling

    Time frame: 12 weeks after starting the intervention

    The time taken for skin temperature of the finger to stabilise in response to localised cooling (in an air temperature of 0oC)

  18. Skin blood flow response to acute cooling

    Time frame: pre-intervention

    Finger Skin blood flow; measurement (using laser Doppler flowmetry) made once finger skin temperature has stabilised in response to localised cooling (in an air temperature of 0oC)

  19. Skin blood flow response to acute cooling

    Time frame: 12 weeks after starting the intervention

    Finger Skin blood flow; measurement (using laser Doppler flowmetry) made once finger skin temperature has stabilised in response to localised cooling (in an air temperature of 0oC)

  20. Skin temperature response to re-warming

    Time frame: pre-intervention

    The time taken for skin temperature of finger to stabilise in an environmental temperature of 25oC following localised cooling (in an air temperature of 0oC)

  21. Skin temperature response to re-warming

    Time frame: 12 weeks after starting the intervention

    The time taken for skin temperature of finger to stabilise in an environmental temperature of 25oC following localised cooling (in an air temperature of 0oC)

  22. Skin temperature after re-warming

    Time frame: pre-intervention

    skin temperature that a finger exposed to an environmental temperature of 25oC stabilises to after localised cooling

  23. Skin temperature after re-warming

    Time frame: 12 weeks after starting the intervention

    skin temperature that a finger exposed to an environmental temperature of 25oC stabilises to after localised cooling

  24. Quality of life score

    Time frame: pre-intervention

    Assessed using SF-36 questionnaire. Responses are coded and normalised to the UK population, as per standard methods, and a score for mental and physical health calculated; a higher score indicating a more favourable outcome

  25. Quality of life score

    Time frame: 4 weeks after starting intervention

    Assessed using SF-36 questionnaire. Responses are coded and normalised to the UK population, as per standard methods, and a score for mental and physical health calculated; a higher score indicating a more favourable outcome

  26. Quality of life score

    Time frame: 8 weeks after starting intervention

    Assessed using SF-36 questionnaire. Responses are coded and normalised to the UK population, as per standard methods, and a score for mental and physical health calculated; a higher score indicating a more favourable outcome

  27. Quality of life score

    Time frame: 12 weeks after starting the intervention

    Assessed using SF-36 questionnaire. Responses are coded and normalised to the UK population, as per standard methods, and a score for mental and physical health calculated; a higher score indicating a more favourable outcome

  28. Attrition rate

    Time frame: 2 years

    Number of participants completing the protocol as a proportion of those who were randomised to the study

  29. Adverse events

    Time frame: 3 months

    Any injury, accident or illness experienced over the intervention period will be documented

  30. Recruitment rate

    Time frame: 2 years

    number of people volunteering to take part in the study as a proportion of those expressing initial interest

Sponsors and collaborators

Lead sponsor

University of Nottingham

Other

Registry information

Official study title

Pilot Study to Investigate the Effect of Cocoa Flavanols on Symptoms in Primary Raynaud's Phenomenon

Important dates

Study start
2018
Primary completion
2020
Study completion
2021
First posted
Jan 24, 2019
Registry last updated
Nov 4, 2021

OpenTrials presents study information sourced from ClinicalTrials.gov. The official registry record should be consulted for the latest information.

View the official ClinicalTrials.gov record (opens in a new tab)

This listing is for discovery and informational purposes only. It is not medical advice, does not guarantee that a study is recruiting, and does not determine eligibility. Contact the study team and a qualified healthcare professional when considering participation.