ankel stirrup
OtherAnkel stirrups are a patient preferred ankel brace that allow active ankle dorsal and plantar flexion during weightbearing while maintaining lateral stability.
NCT Number: NCT07163091
Ankle fractures are common, debilitating and usually treated with immobilisation using a foot-ankle brace (walker). Emerging evidence suggests that a less restrictive brace may reduce recovery time without increasing the risk of complications, and patients tend to prefer ankle stirrups. However, evidence supporting their non-inferiority remains limited and inconclusive. Thus, the aim is assess if an ankle stirrup is non-inferior to a standard walker in reducing pain and function measured by the Manchester-Oxford Foot Questionnaire (MOXFQ) three months after ankle fracture. The hypothesis is that ankel stirrups align better with patients preferenes for less immobilising braces and offer sufficient stability while the fracture heals. Secondarily it may lead to faster recovery of function, return to work and reduced cost. The sample size of a maximum of 1400 patients allow us to assess non-inferiority in age and sex specific subgroups and treatment (surgical or non-sugical). Non-inferiority will be assessed in a pragmatic, multicenter, randomised controlled trial involving Scandinavian orthopedic departments.
Interested in participating?
Request Info18 year and older
All sexes
Interventional
Not applicable
Orthopedic Department, Hospital of Southern Jutland, Aabenraa, Denmark
Ankle fractures are the third most occuring fracture. After an ankle fracture, patients experience reduced ankle function and pain [3]. Also, evidence with moderate to high risk of bias indicate that immobilisation prolong patients recovery. However, high quality evidence are necessary for finite conclusions.
In Scandinavia, foot-ankle braces (walkers) are used to immobilise the fracture while healing. Even though patients acknowledge the need for immobilisation, a qualitative study of ten patients found that patients experienced difficulties in adhering to the recommendation of immobilisation after ankle fracture. A randomised controlled trial (RCT) by Smeeing et al. 2020 found that braces and elastic bands that allow more ankle movement than walkers did not lead to poorer functional outcomes (p=0.56), but may lead to a faster return to work (p = 0.02) without increased complications (p=0.63). The RCT was terminated when half the sample had been included, thus questioning the statistical power of the findings. Based on patient interviews completed during trial preparations we learned that patients preferred ankle stirrups as they allowed movement during use. The same patients also expressed an aversion to the walker, while being hesitant that ankle-supporting elastic bandages provided sufficient support.
Compared to the walker, ankle stirrups may better align with patient preferences while remaining non-inferior in restoring ankle-related outcomes such as pain and function.
Patients will be included in the orthopedic outpatient departments and randomised to a walker or an ankle stirrup. Randomisation will be in blocks to ensure that surgically and non-surgically patients are evenly distributed between groups and that each center will have an equal amount of intervention and control patients. Weightbearing will be unrestricted in both groups so the difference will be the brace (ankel stirrup or walker). Other variation will be a reflection of usual practice. The primary outcome is a validated score including pain, function and social interaction 12 weeks after ankel fracture. The sample size is calculated to 140 patients per each of six subgroups (males 18-39, females 18-39, males 40-59, females 40-59, males 60+, females 60+) randomisation stop when the smallest subgroup (females 18-39 years) reaches 140 or a maximum of 1400 has been included. Patients have been involved in designing the trial and a former ankle fracture patient serves a member of the steering committee.
Healthy volunteers accepted: No
Only the study team can determine whether someone qualifies for participation.
Inclusion criteria
Exclusion criteria
Ankel stirrups are a patient preferred ankel brace that allow active ankle dorsal and plantar flexion during weightbearing while maintaining lateral stability.
Walkers immobilise and stabilise the ankle during weightbearing.
Time frame: Measured as the change from baseline and after 6 and 12 weeks
The index score of the Manchester-Oxford Foot Questionnaire (MOXFQ) three months after randomisation is chosen as the primary outcome. Patients prefer MOXFQ, and it is a valid and reliable self-administered 16-item patient-reported outcome (PRO) divided into three dimensions (walking/standing seven items, pain five items and social interaction four items). MOXFQ will be summarised as an index score covering the most important dimensions patients indicated after ankle fracture (e.g. pain, function and social interaction). Response options consist of a 5-point Likert scale ranging from zero to four. The MOXFQ index score will be calculated by summing the raw scores of the 16 items of the MOXFQ to a index score ranging from a minimum of 0 to a maximum of 100, where 100 represents the most severe health state.
Time frame: Measured as the change from baseline and after 6 and 12 weeks
The short-form International Physical Activity Questionnaire (IPAQ-SF) measure physical activity in five domains, including work-related physical activity, transportation, housework, leisure time and time spent sitting. Patients will be grouped into low, moderate and high physical activity levels depending on activities and time spent doing these activities.
Time frame: Measured as the change from baseline and after 6 and 12 weeks
HRQOL will be measured using the EuroQol five-dimension five-level questionnaire (ed-5d-5l)
Time frame: Measured as the change from baseline and after 6 and 12 weeks
is measured using the knee-to-wall test, which measures ankle mobility in degrees of motion in standing.
Time frame: Measured as the change from baseline and after 6 and 12 weeks
is measured using the heel rise test. Patients perform as many single-leg heel raises at a cadence of one per second until fatigue or a maximum of 50 is reached. The test is performed on both legs, and normal function is recovered if the difference in heel raises between legs is 10% or less.
Time frame: Measured as the total cost from baseline and after 12 weeks
Hospital Costs will be measured from a hospital perspective with a time horizon of three months and include cost of procedures and in-hospital activities.
Time frame: From fracture and until date of return to work.
Will be measured by asking patients what date they returned to work (full-time and part-time). Information on work-related physical requirements (e.g., blue-collar or white-collar workers) and usual employment status (e.g., retiree, unemployed, working) will also be collected.
Time frame: Measured as the change from baseline after 6 and 12 weeks.
The index score of the Manchester-Oxford Foot Questionnaire (MOXFQ) three months after randomisation is chosen as the primary outcome. Patients prefer MOXFQ, and it is a valid and reliable self-administered 16-item patient-reported outcome (PRO) divided into three dimensions (walking/standing seven items, pain five items and social interaction four items). MOXFQ will be summarised as an index score covering the most important dimensions patients indicated after ankle fracture (e.g. pain, function and social interaction). Response options consist of a 5-point Likert scale ranging from zero to four. The MOXFQ index score will be calculated by summing the raw scores of the 16 items of the MOXFQ to a index score ranging from a minimum of 0 to a maximum of 100, where 100 represents the most severe health state and analysed in subgroups: males 18-39, females 18-39, males 40-59, females 40-59, males 60+, females 60+ and in treatment groups (surgical and non-surgical)
Time frame: Safety reporting for each patient will begin at baseline and after 6 and twelve weeks
Adverse events are undesirable experiences that may occur during brace use as: i) skin irritation, blisters, or pressure sores due to poor fit, friction, or prolonged use, ii) swelling or increased edema, iii) pain or discomfort resulting from tightness, misalignment, or mechanical pressure, iv) delayed fracture healing due to excessive joint movement, v) Muscle atrophy or joint stiffness from immobilization, vi) reduced range of motion (ROM) and vii) removal of material (e.g., screws) due to discomfort or healing complications. Serious adverse events are complications requiring hospitalisation, surgical intervention, or posing a significant risk to the patient as i) death (e.g., an unexpected cardiac event occurring during the study period) ii) hospitalisation due to falls resulting from brace-related instability, iii) wound infection requiring inpatient treatment, potentially related to brace-induced i
Time frame: Change from baseline to 6 and 12 months follow-up
The index score of the Manchester-Oxford Foot Questionnaire (MOXFQ) three months after randomisation is chosen as the primary outcome. Patients prefer MOXFQ, and it is a valid and reliable self-administered 16-item patient-reported outcome (PRO) divided into three dimensions (walking/standing seven items, pain five items and social interaction four items). MOXFQ will be summarised as an index score covering the most important dimensions patients indicated after ankle fracture (e.g. pain, function and social interaction). Response options consist of a 5-point Likert scale ranging from zero to four. The MOXFQ index score will be calculated by summing the raw scores of the 16 items of the MOXFQ to a index score ranging from a minimum of 0 to a maximum of 100, where 100 represents the most severe health state.
Time frame: Change from baseline and after 6 and 12 months
Physical activity will be measured in longer term using the short-form International Physical Activity Questionnaire (IPAQ-SF) and grouping patients into low, moderate and high physical activity levels.
Time frame: Baseline and after 6 and 12 months
Long term Health-related Quality Of Life (HRQOL) will be measured using the EuroQol five-dimension five-level questionnaire (ed-5d-5l)
Time frame: Change from baseline and after 6 and 12 months
The index score of the Manchester-Oxford Foot Questionnaire (MOXFQ) three months after randomisation is chosen as the primary outcome. Patients prefer MOXFQ, and it is a valid and reliable self-administered 16-item patient-reported outcome (PRO) divided into three dimensions (walking/standing seven items, pain five items and social interaction four items). MOXFQ will be summarised as an index score covering the most important dimensions patients indicated after ankle fracture (e.g. pain, function and social interaction). Response options consist of a 5-point Likert scale ranging from zero to four. The MOXFQ index score will be calculated by summing the raw scores of the 16 items of the MOXFQ to a index score ranging from a minimum of 0 to a maximum of 100, where 100 represents the most severe health state and analysed in subgroups: males 18-39, females 18-39, males 40-59, females 40-59, males 60+, females 60+ and in treatment groups (surgical and non-surgical)
Time frame: one year from baseline
cost-utility analysis will be completed alongside the clinical trial. Reporting will be from a societal perspective and with an one year timeframe. Utility will be measured in Quality Adjusted Life Years (QALY) by assigning values from the Danish eq-5d-5l reference set (i.e. each health state is assigned a value between -0.759 to 1.000 [40]. The follow-up period will be one year (t4). Costs will be collected from national registris. These, among others, include information on admissions, out-patient visits, home care services, contacts with general practitioners and other private healthcare professionals, prescription medication and welfare subsidies due to sick leave. Hours of informal care the last week patients receive from family and friends will be collected from patients at every follow-up (t1-t4). The reported amount will be assumed stable between time points. Valuation will based on the recommendations of the Health Technology Council and reported in euros (€) using the most
Time frame: From baseline and after 6 and 12 weeks
Carbon footprint of the BAF trial will be estimated by registrering activities associated with design, management and operation of the trial and summing the carbon of to estimate the overall carbon footprint (kgCO2e) using the Clinical Trial Carbon Calculator. Registered activities will be: cradle to gate estimate of ankle stirrups and foot-ankle braces, patients visits to hospital, mean of transportation to visits (car, public or bike, trial staff travel and mean of transportation to recruitments centers.
Time frame: Safety reporting for each patient will begin at baseline and after 6 and 12 months
Adverse events are undesirable experiences that may occur during brace use as: i) skin irritation, blisters, or pressure sores due to poor fit, friction, or prolonged use, ii) swelling or increased edema, iii) pain or discomfort resulting from tightness, misalignment, or mechanical pressure, iv) delayed fracture healing due to excessive joint movement, v) Muscle atrophy or joint stiffness from immobilization, vi) reduced range of motion (ROM) and vii) removal of material (e.g., screws) due to discomfort or healing complications. Serious adverse events are complications requiring hospitalisation, surgical intervention, or posing a significant risk to the patient as i) death (e.g., an unexpected cardiac event occurring during the study period) ii) hospitalisation due to falls resulting from brace-related instability, iii) wound infection requiring inpatient treatment, potentially
Time frame: From baseline and for a minimum of 12 weeks
A subgroup of patients will have their physical activity objectively evaluated using an accelerometer. The SENS Accelerometer is widely used and validated for young and older orthopedic patients. The accelerometer measures total accelerometer counts per day (a valid proxy for physical activity), rest time, standing time, active time (walking time, running, cycling), number of steps, movement intensity and sleep duration for four weeks. The total amount of accelerometer counts will be used to measure the level of physical activity between groups [39]. The accelerometer will be placed on the patients thigh at the day of randomization and followed for a minimum of 12 weeks.
Contact information is provided by the study sponsor or research team.
Bjarke Viberg, Phd
CONTACT
Jonas A Ipsen, phd
CONTACT
Odense University Hospital
Other
Bracing After Ankle Fracture (BAF): a Randomised Multicenter Non-inferiority Trial Comparing Ankle Stirrups to Walkers on Pain, Function and Social Interaction for Adults After Ankle Fracture - Study Protocol
Acronym: BAF
OpenTrials presents study information sourced from ClinicalTrials.gov. The official registry record should be consulted for the latest information.
View the official ClinicalTrials.gov record (opens in a new tab)This listing is for discovery and informational purposes only. It is not medical advice, does not guarantee that a study is recruiting, and does not determine eligibility. Contact the study team and a qualified healthcare professional when considering participation.
Published trials that share one or more normalized conditions with this study.
NCT07521696
Ankle Fracture, Ankle Fractures
Odense, Region Syddanmark, Denmark
View Trial DetailsNCT06863688
Ankle Fracture, Ankle Fractures
Iowa City, Iowa, United States
View Trial DetailsNCT06811090
Ankle Fracture, Ankle Fractures
México, GUSTAVO A MADERO, Mexico
View Trial DetailsNCT06559111
Ankle Fracture, Ankle Fractures
View Trial Details