Skip to main content
OpenTrials
Terminated

NCT Number: NCT03628560

Alternate Methodology of Pulse Oximeter Validation

This study will determine if the replacement of the measured arterial blood oxygen saturation with expired (end-tidal) oxygen value is an acceptable method to calculate the accuracy of pulse oximeters.

Why the study stopped: Limited staff availability
Terminated

Looking for future studies?

Notify Me

Key information

Age range

18 year–50 year

Sex eligibility

All sexes

Study type

Interventional

Phase

Not applicable

Primary location

Duke University

Durham, North Carolina, 27710, United States

About this study

Pulse oximeters are non-invasive devices that use light to display an estimate (denoted by SpO2) of the true arterial blood oxygen saturation (SaO2). The accuracy of the pulse oximeter is determined from desaturation sequences (reduction in SpO2 from 100 to 70%) performed in healthy volunteers. The current standard desaturation sequence is a step-wise reduction in 5% SpO2 increments, achieved by reduction in inspired oxygen delivered by a gas blender such as the ROBD (Reduced Oxygen Breathing Device). This mixes oxygen and nitrogen (components of air) to produce the desired gas mixture. Throughout the desaturation sequence arterial blood gas samples are drawn at each step. The blood gas samples are processed through a co-oximeter to measure the SaO2. For each SaO2 measurement there will be a corresponding SpO2 recorded. All data points from all subjects are amalgamated together to allow calculation of how well SpO2 corresponds to the SaO2 throughout the range of 70 - 100% oxygen saturation. Accuracy, A[RMS], is the unit of measure and this incorporates both bias and precision.

When the ROBD is used in a desaturation sequence, the subjects' arterial blood carbon dioxide (CO2) level will initially be normal (normocapnia). With the reduction in SpO2 during the desaturation sequence, the subjects' breathing rate will increase and this will cause the a physiological reduction in the blood CO2 value (hypocapnia). The extent of hypocapnia will vary from one subject to another. It is not known whether the presence of hypocapnia may have an effect upon the accuracy measurement.

The RespirAct is a gas blender which, in contrast to the ROBD, can control both the oxygen level as well as the carbon dioxide level. The end-tidal oxygen level (PAO2) is continuously displayed by the RespirAct during the desaturation sequence. The PAO2 closely approximates to arterial blood oxygen (PaO2) - the degree of closeness will be measured in the study. Through an accepted formula, the SaO2 can be derived from the measured PAO2. The derived SaO2 values can subsequently be used to measure the accuracy of the pulse oximeter. This A[RMS] can then be compared with the A[RMS] calculated from the blood gas co-oximeter PaO2 / SaO2 values. If the accuracies are comparable then this would remove the need for arterial line placement during pulse oximeter validation studies.

Eligible healthy volunteers will complete five (5) oxygen desaturation sequences with adjustment of sequence type and/or CO2 level. Two sequences will be delivered by step-wise reduction and two will be delivered by gradual slope. Two sequences will be delivered at normocapnia and two will be delivered at hypocapnia values. The ROBD sequence will be a step-wise reduction with CO2 value set by the subjects' own breathing control.

Who can participate

Healthy volunteers accepted: Yes

Only the study team can determine whether someone qualifies for participation.

Inclusion criteria

  • Aged 18 - 50 years
  • Subject is willing to provide written informed consent and is able to comply with anticipated study procedures

Exclusion criteria

  • Body Mass Index (BMI) < 18.0 or > 30.0
  • Known significant respiratory, cardiovascular or medical condition that precludes study participation as judged by investigator
  • Anemia [hemoglobin value below lower range of normal for gender]
  • Abnormal hemoglobin electrophoresis result
  • Exposure to nicotine [positive test at screening or study day]
  • Abnormal drug screen [positive test at screening or on day of study]
  • Positive pregnancy test for females [serum test at screening; urine test on study day]
  • Abnormal Allen's test for collateral circulation
  • Abnormal Electrocardiogram
  • Abnormal Pulmonary Function Test
  • Abnormal venous blood gas result
  • Intolerance of facemask

Treatment and study plan

RespirAct Step-Wise Normocapnia desaturation sequence

Device

Blood carbon dioxide controlled at normal value (normocapnia).

RespirAct Slope Normocapnia desaturation sequence

Device

Blood carbon dioxide controlled at normal value (normocapnia).

RespirAct Step-Wise Hypocapnia desaturation sequence

Device

Blood carbon dioxide controlled at lower than normal value (hypocapnia).

RespirAct Slope Hypocapnia desaturation sequence

Device

Blood carbon dioxide controlled at lower than normal value (hypocapnia).

ROBD Step-Wise desaturation sequence

Device

Blood carbon dioxide is controlled at normal or lower value by subject's own breathing rate.

Primary outcomes

  1. Accuracy of FDA-approved Pulse Oximeter When Calculated With RespirAct-derived End-tidal PAO2 Values

    Time frame: 1 study day

    The unit of measure of accuracy is called Accuracy Root Mean Square Error (A[RMS]) and is a composite value of bias and precision. A[RMS] is reported as a single percentage value representing the overall accuracy of a medical device with lower values indicating better performance.

  2. Accuracy of FDA-approved Pulse Oximeter When Calculated With Co-oximeter Measured Arterial PaO2 Values

    Time frame: 1 study day

    The unit of measure of accuracy is called Accuracy Root Mean Square Error (A[RMS]) and is a composite value of bias and precision. A[RMS] is reported as a single percentage value representing the overall accuracy of a medical device with lower values indicating better performance.

  3. PAO2 Values

    Time frame: 1 study day

    A[RMS] of RespirAct-derived end-tidal PAO2 values with co-oximeter measured arterial PaO2 values. The unit of measure of accuracy is called Accuracy Root Mean Square Error (A[RMS]) and is a composite value of bias and precision. A[RMS] is reported as a single percentage value representing the overall accuracy of a medical device with lower values indicating better performance.

Secondary outcomes

  1. Accuracy, A[RMS], When a Step-wise Desaturation Sequence is Used Against a Slope Desaturation Sequence.

    Time frame: 1 study day

    The unit of measure of accuracy is called Accuracy Root Mean Square Error (A[RMS]) and is a composite value of bias and precision. A[RMS] is reported as a single percentage value representing the overall accuracy of a medical device with lower values indicating better performance.

  2. Level of PaCO2 (Hypocapnia Versus Normocapnia)

    Time frame: 1 study day

    A[RMS] when hypocapnia desaturation is compared to normocapnia desaturation. A[RMS] is reported as a single percentage value representing the overall accuracy of a medical device with lower values indicating better performance.

Sponsors and collaborators

Lead sponsor

Duke University

Other

Registry information

Important dates

Study start
2018
Primary completion
2019
Study completion
2019
First posted
Aug 14, 2018
Registry last updated
Aug 11, 2026

OpenTrials presents study information sourced from ClinicalTrials.gov. The official registry record should be consulted for the latest information.

View the official ClinicalTrials.gov record (opens in a new tab)

This listing is for discovery and informational purposes only. It is not medical advice, does not guarantee that a study is recruiting, and does not determine eligibility. Contact the study team and a qualified healthcare professional when considering participation.

Published trials that share one or more normalized conditions with this study.